By Eric Wynants
During the eleventh and twelfth centuries, the
region known as the Languedoc, spreading approximately southward
from the Loire to the Pyrenees down into Arragon and eastward to the
Rhone, became the most highly civilized area of Western Europe. Its
fertile soil and pleasant climate provided the means for a leisurely
life. The Rhone and the Garonne were notable routes of communication
and the passage of many Crusaders on their way to the East gave an
immense stimulus to trade. Above all the Moslem conquest of Spain
had brought the influence of Arabic culture. The larger cities had
schools of medicine, mathematics and astrology where Arabian
scholarship was imparted. Jews were not debarred from public life
and were highly respected as doctors and teachers. The Catholic
Church no longer held the monopoly of knowledge; and were gradually
losing their power hold in the Languedoc.
The wealth of the monastic
orders and the intolerance of the bishops roused the contempt of the
nobles who accused them of self-indulgence and lack of interest in
the poor. The common priests, through the neglect of their
superiors, had fallen into discredit on account of their poverty and
illiteracy. Very different was the behaviour of the Cathars. Their
eloquence in presenting their beliefs and their untiring care for
all in need of help won the devotion of both nobles and common
people. They became known by the name of bons hommes. When the
leaders of the Catholic Church realized how widely the movement had
spread, it was already too late to stem the tide.

It was inevitable that sooner
or later the clash would come, for no expressions of faith could be
more diametrically opposed between the Catholics and the Cathars.
The heretics were known by a
variety of names. In 1165, they had been condemned by an
ecclesiastical council at the Languedoc town of Albi. For this
reason, or perhaps because Albi continued to be one of their centres,
they were often called Albigensians. On other occasions, they were
called Cathars or Cathares or Cathari. Not infrequently they were
also branded or stigmatized with the names of much earlier heresies
- Arian, Marcionite, and Manichaean.
"Albigensian" and
"Cathar" were essentially generic names. In other words,
they did not refer to a single coherent church, like that of Rome,
with a fixed, codified, and definitive body of doctrine and
theology. The heretics in question comprised a multitude of diverse
sects - many under the direction of an independent leader whose
followers would assume his name. And while these sects may have held
to certain principles, they diverged radically from one another in
details.
And although a conscious
connection between the different groups have sometimes been
exaggerated, a distinct influence of the Persian Manichaens by means
of the Bogomils in Bulgaria, and from there to the Cathars is quite
certain. Deodat Roche in his Cahiers d'Etudes Cathars points out
that Gnosticism and Manichaeanism had a reciprocal influence upon
each other and Manichaean teaching influenced Christian thought. The
nominal even reached China, disappeared as the result of
persecution. The Paulicians, a Manichaean-Christian group, survived
in Asia Minor and Armenia until 872, when they were overrun by the
Greeks and deported to the Balkan peninsula. Here they grew into the
organization that was eventually to become the Cathars.

Cathar dove of Ussat (Ariege)
The originator of Manichaeism,
Mani, came from the southern region of Mesopotamia; he probably was
born on the 14th of April, 216 AD, in the vicinity of
Seleucia-Ctesiphon on the Tigris, the Persian capital. His parents
are said to be of noble Iranian descent, his mother even of Parthian
royal lineage, but this is uncertain. The father, Pattak (Greek:
Parttikios, Latin: Patecius) had joined a gnostic baptist sect to
which he also introduced his son early on. From a recently
discovered source, the Cologne Mania Codex, it is clear that this
was the heretical Jewish Christian community of the Elkesaites,
which claimed to go back to the legendary prophet Elkesai (i.e. the
"hidden power of God") who appeared in about 100 AD in
Syria. The Mandeans, who to this day live in Southern Iraq, also
formed part of this baptist sectarian world which surrounded the
young Mani. When he was twelve years old, in about 228/29, Mani had
his first vision in which his heavenly double, his "twin,"
his "partner" or "companion," appeared to him
and assured him of his constant protection and help. Later, Mani saw
in this the effective revelation of the "comforter," or
the "Holy Spirit," who had revealed to him the
"mysteries" of his teaching.
When Mani was 24 years old, he
confronted King Shapur on the day of his coronation and proclaimed
himself a spiritual leader. Shapur intended to destroy him but
through the persuasion of Shapur's wife Nadir, Mani was called to
the court, at Ghondi-Shapur, as tutor to the King's eldest son. When
the boy fell ill, Mani offered his healing gifts to save the boy's
life. But he failed and the boy died. Mani was consequently
imprisoned.
Mani continued to deepen his
teaching more and more with the coming Christianity so that his
disciples would be better equipped to give the world a new message.
When King Shapur saw his state
religion endangered, he condemned Mani to death. Mani escaped first
to the castle Arabion, thence to Kayak in Mesopotamia. Here he
encountered the Christian bishop Archelaus with whom he had a
dogmatic argument on Christianity; Mani refused to accept the
bishop's dogma and was banned by a religious council. Again, he was
forced to save his life and fled to Khatai in China, and everywhere
he founded Manichaean Communities.
When Mani returned to the
Persian capital, after the death of King Shapur, he had gone through
many mystery experiences. He was a conqueror in Spirit, accomplished
as a human being, a teacher, artist and painter. But the successor
of King Shapur, his son Barahm, was as hostile as his father and
called Mani before a Synod of Persian priests and scholars who
demanded that Mani should recant. When he refused, he was condemned
to death. His decapitated body was skinned and the skin filled with
precious herbs. It was then crucified before the gates of
Ghondi-Shapur as a warning. Ghondi-Shapur was later on in history a
station between Orient and Occident and was of importance for the
spreading of Arabism.
To understand Manichaeism and
its attitude to the forces of evil in man and in the world, we are
greatly dependent on the writings of the opponents of Manichaeism,
especially to those of St. Augustine, the church-father. Augustine's
opposition stemmed from the fact that he was unable to overcome the
darkness within himself. His faith, enhanced and enflamed through an
immeasurable devotion (Credo Quia Absurdum) finds his passionate
expression in his "Confessions." They strike us like a
divine dithyramb of a modern man, an egobearer, who has renounced
knowledge. Tortured by unanswerable questions, Augustine wrestles
with the problem of pre-existence.
The Manicheans saw in the
search for the evil itself the beginning of the transformation. This
search was an act of cognition. What is the origin of evil? Evil is
in the first instance a displaced good. What in one sphere or at one
time is right and good, is evil in another sphere or at another
time.
The Manichaens believed that in
the course of repeated earth lives the light element will be
victorious over the darkness, in a process of gradual
soul-transformation. Man will become a co-fighter of the King of
Light against the Regent of Darkness.
Nicetas, the Bulgarian mystic
who several times travelled through Southern France, is said to have
laid the foundations of a new church at Saint-Felix de Caraman, and
entrusted to certain men, whom he recognised as being pure of heart,
the book in which the "spiritual doctrine" was embodied.
Nothing is known of him, except the deep impression left by his
visit and the extension of the Catharist movement which followed his
departure for Sicily.
The Cathars were part of the
movement of the "poor," dating back to older times. And of
which, for example, the hermits who, at the beginning of the
Christian era, lived around the Mediterranean were a part. During
the 12th century, this movement was taken up idealistically by the
people at large. The way into poorness was in reality the way into
the deeper realms of the higher "I." The "Monachos"
went all the way within, to have a dialogue with "God."
Wealth, therefore, was being rejected by the Cathars as
"external." The way of the Troubadour, on the other hand,
valued the ego as a result of self-knowledge. The values contained
in the ego, had to come to fruition in order to reach completion. So
the Cathars represented more the inward path, the Troubadours the
other.
Side by side with the
Troubadours, Catharism spread with extraordinary speed in Southern
France. It was the radiant cult of the pure spirit which took
possession of men's souls, and it seriously endangered the
materialistic Church of the Pope. Innocent III realised this and
dispatched several apostolic legates to Southern France. These
legates went to Toulouse, which was the capital of Catharism. They
were resolved to strike a resounding blow, which should bring misery
and terror to the south.

In general the Cathars
subscribed to a doctrine of reincarnation and to a recognition of
the feminine principle in religion. Indeed, the preachers and
teachers of Cathar congregations were of both sexes. At the same
time, the Cathars rejected the orthodox Catholic Church and denied
the validity of all clerical hierarchies, all official and ordained
intercessors between man and God. At the core of this position lay a
gnostic tenet - the repudiation of "faith," at least as
the Church insisted on it. In the place of "faith"
accepted at secondhand, the Cathars insisted on direct and personal
knowledge, a religious or mystical experience apprehended at
firsthand.
The Cathars were heirs to
knowledge which partly came from the East and was known to the
Gnostics and the early Christians. The basis of this secret was the
transmission of the power of love. The gesture of the rite was the
material and visible means of projecting this power. Behind it was
hidden the spiritual gift, by which the soul was helped, and was
able to cross without suffering the narrow portal of death, to
escape the shadows and become merged with the light.
In the Black Mountain, not far
from Carcassone, there was found a chamber, dating from the Cathar
period, containing skeletons. "They lay in a circle, with their
heads at the center and their feet at the circumference, like the
spokes of a wheel." Those who have studied magical rites will
recognise in this posture of death a very ancient rite intended to
facilitate the escape of the soul, to allow it to traverse the
intermediate worlds by virtue of the impetus given by union.
The logical consequence of the
Cathar philosophy is that life is evil and that it is expedient to
escape from the form in which we are confined. The principle of
creation, God the Creator, is consequently evil, since he has
created form, which is the cause of evil. He is the Jehovah of the
Old Testament, angry, destructive, who takes pleasure in punishment
and revenge. The Cathars saw in this terrible God the retrograde
power of matter. Jesus Christ, the symbol of the Word, came to teach
man the means of escaping from this God and returning to the Kingdom
of Heaven. Certain of them affirmed that Jesus had no terrestrial
existence, that he only came among men clothed in a spiritual body,
and that the miracles recounted in the New Testament had a symbolic
character and had been performed only on the spiritual plane. The
blind were healed only of spiritual blindness, because they were
blinded by sin. The tomb whence Lazarus rose from the dead was the
dark abode in which man voluntarily imprisons himself. The true cult
of the Cathars was the cult of the Holy Spirit, the divine Paraclete.
That is to say, of the principle which enables the human spirit to
attain the "real world," the invisible world, the world of
pure light, "the permanent and unaltered city."
The conclusions which might be
drawn from this creed seemed, for all their strict logic, monstrous
to men of the twelfth century, as they would seem monstrous to men
of the twentieth. Suicide, to escape the evils of life, which were
still further aggravated by the persecutions, was at least allowed,
if it was not actually enjoined.
The Cathars, like the Romans
under the Empire, sought death gladly by opening their veins. But
they were forbidden to end their lives unless they had attained
absolute calm, complete indifference, in order to escape a death
incurred in circumstances of agony. The executioners of the
Inquisition often found Cathar adepts lifeless in their cells, their
white faces showing the reflection of the eternal light towards
which they were journeying.
Among them women played an
unexpected part. They were the equals of men. And many relatives of
the Languedoc Seigneurs, were in charge of centres of instruction
and healing.
In many respects, Cathar ritual
reflected the practices of the early pre-Constantine Church. There
is also a link with the common ancestors of Freemasonry in that the
Cathar candidate was addressed as "a living stone in the temple
of God." Mani already had been called a "son of the widow.

Otto Rahn In Cathar Cave
During the eleventh and twelfth
centuries, there had been sporadic burnings of Cathar heretics; but
it gradually became apparent that these measures had no effect. In
1179 Pope Alexander III pronounced an Anathema against the sect and
sent Papal legates ordering the nobles of the Languedoc to take
strong disciplinary measures. The report was brought back to him
that the disease was far too widespread to be dealt with in this
way. When Innocent III came to the Papal throne he determined to
bring an end to this scandalous opposition to his authority. He
first tried measures of conciliation. In 1203 he launched a
preaching campaign to convert all who were straying from the true
path. In the chief towns of the Languedoc a series of public debates
was arranged. Leading heretics were to meet the Pope's legates and
each side was to expound its teaching. It was a remarkable gesture
to allow heretics to speak on equal terms with the orthodox, but the
Pope imagined that the truth of Catholic dogma must win the day.
The legates arrived in their
splendid robes with cavalcades of followers, demanding almost royal
hospitality; while the Cathar Perfecti appeared in their modest
simplicity. The populace loved the "bons hommes" and
despised the haughty representatives of Rome; so the Catholics made
little progress.
There came, however, a
surprising diversion. Two Spanish monks, fired with missionary zeal,
arrived on the scene. The more energetic of the two, Dominic de
Guzman, later to become the famous St. Dominic, reproved the legates
for their ostentation and arrogance. He himself even out did the
Perfecti in asceticism. When the mob flung mud and threatened to
kill him, he replied, "I should beg you not to kill me at one
blow, but to tear me limb from limb; I would like to be a mere
limbless trunk, with eyes gouged out, wallowing in my own blood,
that I might thereby win a worthier martyr's crown!" Such
intrepidity won an awed respect, but in spite of Dominic's ardent
eloquence, no converts of great importance appeared.
There lived at that time in
Toulouse, in the rue du Taur, a venerable old man named Pierre
Maurand, who had been the host of Nicetas and held nocturnal
meetings at which he preached the new religion. He was compared to
St. John on account of his shining eyes. He was a capitoul
(magistrate) and one of the richest men in Toulouse. The legates
summoned him solemnly before the people, interrogated him, convicted
him of heresy and condemned him to death. The strength of a martyr
was not in him. He feared death, which is usually harder for a rich
old man than to other men, and promised to return to the Roman
Catholic Church. But his return was made difficult. He was compelled
to walk barefoot from the prison to the church of Saint-Sernin
between the Bishop of Toulouse and one of the legates, who beat him
unmercifully with rods. At the church he asked pardon on his knees,
recanted, and listened to his sentence, which was that he should
have his houses destroyed and his property confiscated. He had,
further, to go to the Holy Land and for three years to devote
himself to the succour of the poor of Jerusalem. Before his
departure, moreover, in order that no inhabitant of Toulouse should
remain in ignorance of his recantation, he was obliged for forty
days to visit every church in Toulouse, scourging himself meanwhile.
Pierre Maurand, who was then
eighty years old, scourged himself and wandered naked about the
streets for the prescribed forty days. After that he left Toulouse,
crossed the sea and came to the East. He visited Arabia to discuss
mystical subjects with the Persian Sufi, Farid Uddin, stayed in
Tripoli, learned about the Maimonid philosophy, spent three years in
Jerusalem and returned to Toulouse, where his friends had never
thought to see him again. His career was not yet at an end. It was
hardly more than a beginning. Typical of the stubborn men of
Toulouse, he started once more preaching secretly, and for five
consecutive periods of three years he was elected consul of the town
by his fellow-citizens, who desired to honour him as the national
resistance to a foreign pope.
People had grown so used to the
idea that death could not take him that it was thought for a long
time that he had taken refuge in the forests of Comminges; and a
century and a half later inhabitants of the outskirts of Toulouse
claimed to have seen Pierre Maurand going the rounds of the ramparts
to examine their strength, leaning on his stick and erect as ever.
The south had been terrified by
the condemnation of Pierre Maurand. A pope who dared lay hands on
this noble old man must be the pope of evil. Catharism grew; the
churches were abandoned. A new Church came secretly into being,
without buildings, without a hierarchy, without grand vestments. The
voice of Dominic the Spaniard rang in vain in the public squares.
More drastic measures had to be
taken. The Pope sent his legate, Peter of Castelnau, to discipline
Count Raymond of Toulouse for harboring and supporting heretics;
and, as the Count failed to act effectively, he was excommunicated.
Then, almost certainly without the Count's sanction one of his
followers kindled the spark which fired the conflagration. In 1208,
while crossing the Rhone on his return to Italy, Peter of Castelnau
was murdered. The crime seems to have been committed by
anti-clerical rebels with no Cathar affiliation whatever. Furnished
with the excuse she needed, however, Rome did not hesitate to blame
the Cathars. At once Pope Innocent III ordered a crusade. Although
there had been intermittent persecution of heretics all through the
previous century, the Church now mobilized her forces in earnest.
The heresy was to be extirpated once and for all.

Raymond of Toulouse realized
the danger but he failed to form an alliance with his fellow nobles.
The Counts of the South had no common policy and were only too ready
to suspect one another of crying to gain undue power. Raymond then
decided on the clever ruse of doing penance to win back a position
in the Catholic church and of joining the Crusade. In this way he
secured the safety of his own people, for the Crusading army was now
prevented from entering his realm. His nephew and vassal, Raymond
Roger Trencavel, Viscount of Beziers and Carcassonne, decided to
defend his own realms.
The Crusading army made rapid
progress along the course of the Rhone. In the early thirteenth
century, most of the leading nobles relied to a great extent on
mercenaries. With the progress of civilization knights no longer
regarded fighting as their role task and, though many were still
loyal to their overlords, their support was erratic, as their
obligation to fight was traditionally for a period of only forty
days. The mercenaries, having no personal loyalty or standard of
honor, were brutal and godless. They could expect no consideration
from their leaders.
On the 21st of July 1209, an
army of some thirty thousand knights and foot soldiers from northern
Europe descended like a whirlwind on the Languedoc - the mountainous
northeastern foothills of the Pyrenees in what is now Southern
France. In the ensuing war, the whole territory was ravaged, crops
were destroyed, towns and cities were razed, a whole population was
put to the sword. This extermination occurred on so vast, so
terrible a scale that it may well constitute the first case of
"genocide" in modern European history. In the town of
Beziers alone, for example, at least fifteen thousand men, women,
and children were slaughtered wholesale - many of them in the
sanctuary of the church itself. When an officer inquired of the
Pope's representative how he might distinguish heretics from true
believers, the reply was, "Kill them all. God will recognize
his own." This quotation, though widely reported, may be
apocryphal. Nevertheless, it typifies the fanatical zeal and
bloodlust with which the atrocities were perpetrated. The same papal
representative, writing to Innocent III in Rome, announced proudly
that "neither age nor sex nor status was spared."

Surviving Cathars disappeared
into remote hiding places in the forests and mountain clefts of the
Pyrenees. Yet it is known that many of the Perfecti travelled freely
from place to place, comforting and encouraging their followers, who
risked death in keeping them provided with food and other
necessities. From time to time, citizens of the towns which
capitulated were commanded to affirm their loyalty to the Catholic
faith. Those who refused were burned to death, but no real
suppression of the heresy was achieved and no attempt was made by de
Montfort to win the support of the population.
The leaders of the Cathars
realized that steps should be taken to protect their Order. As early
as 1204 Raymond de Perella had been requested by them to repair the
fortress of Montsegur of which he was the Seigneur. At first, this
remote refuge seems to have been used only as centre of pilgrimage,
but from 1233 onwards it became the heart of the resistance
movement. The origin of this fortress is a mystery as it was not
constructed according to any accepted plan of defense. It guarded no
main route and protected no fertile district; it seemed more fitted
for a sanctuary, secluded in its wild forbidding surroundings. It is
thought that it may once have been a Celtic temple.
The incisive observations of
Fernand Niel in his book, Montsegur, the Holy Mountain (Montsegur,
la montagne inspiree), prove that the layout of the edifice lends
itself to plotting with astonishing accuracy the principal positions
of the sun in its ascendancy. An ancient Manichaean temple
consecrated to sun worship, Montsegur became the Mount Tabor of the
Cathari by means of a spiritual affiliation which today is
practically impossible to deny.
Other castles in Aquitaine, it
should be noted, such as Queribus in the Corbieres (which also
served as an Albigensian refuge) and Puivert (where the mother of
Trencavel, Viscount of Carcassonne, held her court of love), possess
an architecture much like that of Montsegur.
Henri Coltel, who conducted
extensive research on this subject in southwestern France,
discovered important evidence confirming Fernand Niel's findings. He
saw some forty-odd subterranean passageways dating back to the
eleventh and twelfth centuries, and he found that all of the
subterraneans have a chapel hall wherein is found a sort of altar;
for a given region all the subterraneans are so oriented that they
converge toward a single point. Coltel became convinced that they
were not primarily refuges, but rather temples where the Cathars,
before the period of the persecutions, celebrated their initiation
ceremonies. Montsegur became the last stronghold of the Cathar
movement.
Yet in 1242, the invading
armies in collaboration with the church, decided to attack Montsegur.
And by April of 1243, a vast army of more than ten thousand
surrounded the mountain.

With this vast force, the
besiegers attempted to surround the entire mountain, precluding all
entry and exit and hoping to starve out the defenders. Despite their
numerical strength, however, they lacked sufficient manpower to make
their ring completely secure. Many troops were local, moreover, and
sympathetic to the Cathars. And many troops were simply unreliable.
In consequence it was not difficult to pass undetected through the
attackers' lines. There were many gaps through which men slipped to
and fro, and supplies found their way up to the fortress.
The Cathars took advantage of
these gaps. In January 1244, nearly three months before the fall of
the fortress, two parfaits escaped. According to reliable accounts,
they carried with them the bulk of the Cathars' material wealth - a
load of gold, silver, and coin that they carried first to a
fortified cave in the mountains and from there to a castle
stronghold. After that the treasure vanished and has never been
heard of again.

On March 1, Montsegur finally
capitulated. By then its defenders numbered less than 400 - between
150 and 180 of them were parfaits, the rest being knights, squires,
men-at-arms, and their families. They were granted surprisingly
lenient terms. The fighting men were to receive full pardon for all
previous "crimes." They would be allowed to depart with
their arms, baggage, and any gifts, including money, they might
receive from their employers. The parfaits were also accorded
unexpected generosity. Provided they abjured their heretical beliefs
and confessed their "sins" to the Inquisition, they would
be freed and subjected only to light penances. Yet, they decided not
to do so.
Were the parfaits so committed
to their beliefs that they willingly chose martyrdom instead of
conversion? Or was there something they could not - or dared not -
confess to the Inquisition? Whatever the answer, not one of the
parfaits, as far is known, accepted the besiegers' terms. On the
contrary, all of them chose martyrdom. Moreover, at least twenty of
the other occupants of the fortress, six women and some fifteen
fighting men, voluntarily received the Consolamentum and became
parfaits as well, thus committing themselves to certain death.
On March 15, the truce expired.
At dawn the following day more than two hundred parfaits were
dragged roughly down the mountainside. Not one recanted. There was
not time to erect individual stakes. They were locked into a large
wood-filled stockade at the foot of the mountain and burned en
masse.
Documents of the Inquisition
confirm that the night preceding the capitulation of Montsegur, four
Cathars let themselves down on ropes along the veniginous side of
the mountain (Aican, Poitevin, Hugh, and Alfaro) and managed to make
good their escape into the surrounding mountains, carrying off with
them the sacred treasure. Tradition has it that when the Grail had
been saved, a flame appeared on the neighboring mountain of Biaorta,
announcing to the Cathari of Montsegur that they could now lie in
peace. The Grail stone, or sacred book, was doubtless hidden in one
of the innumerable grottoes of the Sabarthez. The story told by an
old shepherd goes:

This cave was the last refuge of the Cathari parfaits.
During the time when the walls
of Montsegur were still standing, the Cathars kept the Holy Grail
there. Montesegur was in danger, the armies of Lucifer had besieged
it. They wanted the Grail, to restore it to their Prince's diadem
from which it had fallen during the fall of the angels. Then, at the
most critical moment, there came down from heaven a white dove
which, with its beak, split Tabor in two. Esclarmonde, who was
keeper of the Grail, threw the sacred jewel into the depths of the
mountain. The mountain closed up again, and in this manner was the
Grail saved. When the devils entered the fortress, they were too
late. Enraged, they put to death by fire all of the Pures, not far
from the rock on which the castle stands, in the champ des cremats,
the Field of the Stake... All of the Pures perished on the pyre,
except Esclarmonde de Foix. When she knew the Grail to be safe, she
climbed to the summit of Mount Tabor, changed into a white dove, and
flew off toward the mountains of Asia. Esclarmonde is not dead. Even
now she lives over there, in the "earthly Paradise."
© Copyright New Dawn Magazine,
http://www.newdawnmagazine.com .
Permission granted to freely distribute this article for
non-commercial purposes if unedited and copied in full, including
this notice.