8/02/05
http://www.mccurtain.com/articles/2005/08/02/news/news001.txt
By J.D. Cash and Lt. Colonel Roger Charles (U.S.M.C.
retired)
Newly released documents received by a Salt Lake City attorney in
his suit against the Oklahoma City FBI office provide the strongest
evidence yet that the U.S. Department of Justice (DOJ) has been
conducting a well-orchestrated cover-up of evidence linking Timothy
McVeigh to subjects that frequented, and in some cases resided, at
an eastern Oklahoma paramilitary compound called Elohim City.
At the center of this cabal were numerous informants. At least
two of those providing critical information about the Elohim City
conspiracy reported to a tax-exempt civil rights group, the Southern
Poverty Law Center (SPLC), headed by Morris Dees.
Perhaps even more surprising is evidence in these 87 pages
released by DOJ on behalf of the FBI and the Oklahoma City FBI
office, is documentation showing that top FBI agents assigned the
bombing case lacked authority to conduct interviews at Elohim City
or to go after a leading suspect in the case, Andreas Carl
Strassmeir, also known as "Andy the German."
While the state's media ignored (and some even attacked) evidence
this newspaper presented nine years ago linking McVeigh, Terry
Nichols and Mike Fortier to Strassmeir and other radicals at Elohim
City, these new but heavily redacted documents should provide a
starting point for a real investigation into the horrific crime and
apparent government sponsored cover-up.
Trentadue suit
After months of legal wrangling in a Salt Lake City courtroom,
the DOJ reluctantly turned over 17 FBI-generated documents Friday,
to the plaintiff in a Freedom Of Information Act (FOIA) lawsuit n
Jesse C. Trentadue.
Trentadue, a well-respected Salt Lake City lawyer whose client
list is made up of members of the insurance industry, became
embroiled in the Oklahoma City bombing case after his brother was
found beaten to death in his jail cell at the Oklahoma City Federal
Transfer Center in August 1995.
Initially, the federal government ruled Kenny Trentadue's death a
suicide, in spite of many indications that pointed to his having
been beaten to death. The Trentadue family and local investigators
tried to obtain definitive proof of his murder, but were thwarted by
actions of FBI and Bureau of Prison employees who allegedly
destroyed evidence in the case.
After information was passed to him from an intermediary serving
time at a Terre Haute, Ind., federal prison with McVeigh, Jesse
Trentadue sought evidence of his brother's death inside the OKBOMB
investigation files.
McVeigh's message offered an explanation as to why such extreme
measures had been undertaken by federal officials: Kenny Trentadue
was tortured by federal agents who may have mistakenly thought he
was a member of the bombing conspiracy.
With this tenuous lead from McVeigh, the dead man's brother filed
a FOIA request for documents that could shed light on his brother's
brutal murder and the OKBOMB case.
In the course of his investigation, evidence emerged in documents
Trentadue received that the FBI was using the SPLC to gather
information on Elohim City n both before and after the bombing.
After months of legal maneuvering by the DOJ and the FBI, U.S.
District Court Judge Dale Kimball ruled on May 5, 2005, that the
Oklahoma City FBI office had to search for documents linking the
SPLC to Elohim City and/or specific individuals connected to the
April 19, 1995, bombing.
With national attention on the case provided by several news
agencies, the FBI released a small portion of what may prove to be a
large reservoir of hidden documents that could reveal more
sensational details about a widespread cover-up.
The DOJ cover letter accompanying the newly released documents
claimed the release to Trentadue was done as "a matter of
discretion, in the interest of resolving the litigation in good
faith." The earliest date on these documents is a teletype
transmitted on April 24, 1995 n only three days after McVeigh was
first publicly identified as a prime suspect in the bombing of the
A.P. Murrah federal building.
While each of the 17 reports is heavily redacted, central to
these-never-before-reported-on documents is evidence that the
Southern Poverty Law Center headquartered in Montgomery, Ala., was
monitoring neo-Nazi radicals closely associated with McVeigh, if not
McVeigh himself, shortly before McVeigh's deadly attack.
Leaked teletype first
disclosed SPLC connection
What started this latest litigation was an article first reported
by this newspaper on Dec. 14, 2003. The copyrighted article provided
details of a teletype sent by the director of the FBI to a select
few FBI offices, disclosing that Morris Dees' SPLC had at least one
informant at Elohim City on April 17, 1995, when McVeigh called the
camp.
The name of the individual to whom McVeigh placed this call is
redacted in the FBI teletype, but a phone card shows at another time
McVeigh called Elohim City to speak to Strassmeir.
Strassmeir was providing paramilitary training to the neo-Nazis
who frequently cycled through Elohim City. This January 4, 1996, FBI
teletype also documents an April 5, 1995, telephone call from
McVeigh to Elohim City, characterizing this call as an attempt by
McVeigh "to recruit a second conspirator to assist in the OKBOMB
attack.
One of the newly released FBI documents, dated January 26, 1996,
provides support for the accuracy of the SPLC informant's
characterization of McVeigh's April 5 telephone call as a
"recruiting" call.
In this newly disclosed report, the FBI notes that Fortier,
identified as "the OKBOMB cooperating subject" (but with his name
redacted), as having said that, "April 5, 1995, was around the time
that he backed out of the plans to bomb the federal building.
McVeigh may have been trying to recruit other individuals to assist
him."
This new evidence from the top echelons of the FBI directly
contradicts many statements made in federal court by top DOJ
officials, who told federal judges they were not aware of any
government information about any informants operating inside Elohim
City before the bombing.
In closed chambers, DOJ lawyers told U.S. District Judge Richard
Matsch that they had no evidence linking anyone at Elohim City to
McVeigh, or the bombing, other than a calling card record showing
McVeigh had called the camp a single time on April 5, 1995.
Furthermore, these same DOJ attorneys said absolutely nothing
about an April 17, 1995 call by McVeigh, while at least one
operative from the SPLC was present at Elohim City, monitoring the
compound, when McVeigh called.
Stephen Jones, McVeigh's attorney at that trial, indicated that
the new documents show prosecutors violated ethical standards.
"These hand-picked DOJ lawyers were obligated by law and by their
professional code of ethics to provide this information to Judge
Matsch in order for him to determine if the material should be
turned over to the McVeigh and Nichols defense teams. They did not
do so," he said.
Conspiracy closely monitored
Taken in their entirety, Utah attorney Jesse Trentadue's latest
documents clearly place the role of the SPLC and its own undercover
operatives at the center of unresolved issues about federal law
enforcement's prior knowledge of the conspiracy to bomb a federal
building in Oklahoma City on April 19, 1995.
In addition, the documents also show that members of the DOJ
prosecution team misrepresented to U.S. District Judge Richard
Matsch the true extent of government files about McVeigh's ties to
Elohim City, potentially opening them up to criminal prosecution and
disbarment for these misrepresentations.
One of those documents indicates that on April 24, 1995, a top
DOJ lawyer in the civil rights division, Barry Kowalski, reported
that he was seeking an interview with a key undercover SPLC source
about relations the source had developed regarding, "relationships,
activities, and/or associates of subject number one, Timothy J.
McVeigh."
Indeed, the FBI was using a spy network operated by the SPLC to
do what many in the FBI were afraid to do because of guidelines in
place during the Clinton administration.
According to a highly placed confidential source in the DOJ at
the time of the bombing, Attorney General Janet Reno would not allow
the FBI much latitude in developing intelligence inside the
far-right due to concerns that such activities might violate
existing departmental guidelines on "domestic spying."
To skirt Reno's policies, the FBI developed a relationship with
cutouts such as the SPLC that could use their own spies to do what
the FBI could not. These non-government agents then passed their
intelligence products back to the bureau.
Dees confirms relationship
In December 2003 this newspaper presented SPLC co-founder Morris
Dees with information that linked his organization to the FBI and to
McVeigh's conspiracy in the months before the Ryder truck exploded.
Dees confirmed to the Gazette a role in the surveillance
operation at Elohim City (and other places) when reporters
interviewed him at a press conference in Durant.
Dees was initially taken aback when he learned that the newspaper
had obtained an officially released FBI teletype from director Louis
Freeh, including information attributed to an SPLC informant who was
present Elohim City on April 17, 1995, when McVeigh called him to
seek help in the bombing.
Dees admitted that he had an informant at Elohim City as the
teletype said. However, the coy attorney refused to elaborate on the
situation, except to say he had warned then-attorney general Reno,
six months before the attack, that, "(A)n attack on the government
is planned by members of the far right."
Dees went on to say that after the attack he immediately called
Reno to say the media had it wrong.
"I told her the attack was domestic, not foreign," Dees said.
The co-founder of the SPLC also said that he did not know McVeigh by
name before the blast. However, Dees did become visibly shaken when
asked what he thought of German-national Andreas Strassmeir.
"I won't ever discuss that man," Dees said as he spun away from the
interview and left the press conference with his armed bodyguards in
tow.
Book discloses informant
In the newly released April 24, 1995, teletype, the FBI and DOJ
redacted the name of the SPLC agent, but described him as "acting in
various undercover capacities for the purposes of gathering
intelligence for that organization [the SPLC]."
Dees, on the other hand, had no such concerns about identifying
this operative in his 1996 book, "Gathering Storm: America's Militia
Threat." There he described Mike Reynolds as "one of our [SPLC]
Militia Task Force investigators." Dees' description of Reynolds'
itinerary for the period in question perfectly fits the description
in the April 24 teletype.
The EC connection
An appraisal of the new documents shows that almost immediately
after the bombing, elements within the FBI sought information about
Strassmeir, the paramilitary leader at Elohim City. And the
information was sourced through Dees' information network at Elohim
City, according to these same FBI documents.
The first report provided by the Oklahoma City FBI office
concerning the SPLC's intelligence operation was prepared on April
24, 1995, and discusses McVeigh's links to the Michigan Militia and
to the Arizona Patriots militia group n a group that the SPLC
informant stated had evolved into the Constitution Ranger's militia
group.
The informant cited this latter group's involvement in white
supremacist activities in the Kingman, Ariz., area and claimed to be
knowledgeable "of the identities of various members who had
association with Timothy Jack (sic) McVeigh."
The FBI document said this SPLC informant had just attended an
neo-Nazi movement rally and as of April 24 was staying at the Hilton
Inn in Little Rock when the FBI attempted to make contact, but had
departed for the Montgomery, Ala., area "within the past one hour."
But the initial report from the Oklahoma City FBI office does not
mention the fact that at least one, and very likely two informants
for the SPLC were at Elohim City on April 17, 1995, when McVeigh
made the call never disclosed by the DOJ to Judge Matsch.
Those details would not come out for many months, and then only
after the FBI learned that one of the reporters for this story (J.D.
Cash) and an investigator for McVeigh's defense team were making
regular visits to Elohim City.
In January 1996, this newspaper began preparing a series of
articles about Elohim City. Those articles were based upon multiple
trips to the compound in late 1995.
According to people at the compound, McVeigh had visited the camp
several times. The leaders of the camp, though, would make that
information only on a non-attribution basis n out of fear, they
said, that they would be linked to the bombing and arrested for
conspiracy.
At one point in the questioning of Rev. Robert Millar, the aging
patriarch of the Christian Identity community of about 80 persons,
he admitted to McVeigh defense investigator Richard Reyna in the
presence of a reporter for this newspaper that McVeigh's initial
visit to Elohim City had been with former KKK leader Dennis Mahon of
Tulsa.
Before long, several others provided the same details. McVeigh
had traveled to Elohim City for meetings inside and outside the
compound well over a dozen times, beginning in the fall of 1993.
One of the sources, an Oklahoma state trooper, had informants inside
the neo-Nazi compound. A second source is none other than Morris
Dees himself.
Reported by veteran reporter Howard Pankratz in the Denver Post,
on May 16, 1996, Dees was quoted as saying that McVeigh has visited
Elohim City,"…. on a number of occasions."
Sometime after that article appeared, Dees attempted to recant
his declaration, claiming he had been misquoted, but the reporter
who wrote the article was adamant that Dees had spoken as quoted in
the article.
Contacted this week, Pankratz said he recalls attending the press
luncheon and may even have Dees' comments on a tape.
"I kept all my Oklahoma City interview material," Pankratz noted.
"Dees certainly never asked us to print a retraction of our story."
Suspects flee Elohim City
By the late summer of 1995, because of increasing media interest
and law enforcement attention on Elohim City, several young men,
including German National Andreas "Andy the German" Strassmeir, fled
Elohim City n a neo-Nazi paramilitary camp in eastern Oklahoma.
Three of these men n Scott Stedford, Kevin McCarthy and Michael
Brescia n were subsequently arrested for participating in a series
of bank robberies in the Midwest and attempting to overthrow the
government. The gang called itself the Aryan Republic Army (ARA).
All three of these men shared living quarters at Elohim City with
Strassmeir.
While the FBI for years told the media that the agency had no
interest in Strassmeir and any alleged connections to Tim McVeigh
and the OKC bombing, these new documents establish that some key
officials inside the FBI were monitoring Strassmeir's escape from
the U.S. n but were doing nothing to stop him from leaving.
Contained in an unclassified teletype marked "Priority" from the
London FBI office to the director of the FBI on Jan. 4, 1996, the
OKBOMB case number is referenced and the following information is
provided:
"Poverty Law Center, Montgomery, Alabama who had received the
following information from various confidential sources: [redacted
name] white male, date of birth [information redacted] he was helped
with [information redacted] also defends [information redacted].
Additionally in November of 1993, [name redacted] met subject Tim
McVeigh (and) [name redacted] and thereafter, became associates with
McVeigh because of their common background [information redacted] in
the military.
[name and information redacted] for the past few years at Elohim
City, Oklahoma (a religious white supremacist community in a remote
area) McVeigh attempted to call [name redacted] in April of 1995
prior to the bombing, according to this source.
[name redacted] went on to provide additional information from
his sources regarding [names and information redacted. Name
redacted] concluded by advising that he has provided this
information to the FBI because he has heard that LEGAT [legal
attaché], London (FBI London) is doing background investigation on
[name redacted]. "
LEGAT is the short name for the office of the FBI's Legal Attache
at the specified U.S. embassy. The LEGAT is an FBI agent assigned to
the staff of the U.S. ambassador for liaison duties with law
enforcement officials in that foreign country.
The DOJ acknowledged that McVeigh called Elohim City on April 5,
1995, asking for Strassmeir. Both Strassmeir and McVeigh had common
military experiences. Other sources confirm that LEGAT London was
tasked to do a background investigation on Strassmeir.
Given these facts, and the limited pool of "players," it is clear
that the teletype mentioned above can only refer to Strassmeir, who
was expected to flee the U.S. shortly, and did.
The document goes on to say: "Will advise Oklahoma City command
post whether LEGAT is aware of any investigation [name and
information redacted] by LEGAT, London, Scotland Yard, Interpol, or
any similar agency in your jurisdiction."
Referring to the November 1993 trip McVeigh made to Elohim City,
this newspaper broke a story on July 1 about an interview Terry
Nichols gave Congressman Dana Rohrabacher, R-Calif.
That jailhouse interview included Nichols' admissions for the
first time that in the fall of 1993 he and McVeigh traveled to
Elohim City. During the course of the Rohrabacher interview, Nichols
also told the congressman that it was clear to him that McVeigh had
been to the compound before and knew Strassmeir and others there
"very well."
DOJ officials hamper probe
Many of those new unclassified documents also establish that the
OKBOMB task force was unable to interview subjects connected with
Elohim City, because of conditions set forth by FBI director Louis
Freeh and possibly other high ranking DOJ officials.
As an example: In a very unusual teletype, Jan. 29, 1996, marked
"Priority" from the OKBOMB command post, which was headed at the
time by Supervisory Special Agent Danny Defenbaugh, the commander of
the massive investigation asked Freeh to locate Strassmeir in
Germany and have someone question him about the numerous details set
forth in newspaper articles detailing Strassmeir's connections to
the bombing conspirators.
Not only were many of the names redacted from this priority
teletype to Freeh; even the name of the newspaper breaking the
Strassmeir/McVeigh/EC connections was withheld by the Oklahoma
City FBI office.
However, based on the teletype's description of one of the
informants providing information to the bureau, it is likely that
Dennis Mahon is one of the sources referred to. The memo notes that
Mahon (whose name was redacted) had a long history of contacts with
members of radical rightwing and the skinheads. It also notes that
the informant was recently barred from a particular foreign country
he visited and stirred up trouble.
Indeed, Mahon had been barred from Germany for participating in
Ku Klux Klan activities there during the timeframe mentioned in the
teletype.
The FBI's Oklahoma City Command Post also said its informant
provided information that Strassmeir had left Elohim City in the
past few months and moved to Black Mountain, N.C.
The information was further verified by a "CW" n a Cooperating
Witness n informant from the FBI's Cincinnati division n a man
closely allied with the Aryan Republican Army (ARA) and a longtime
source of information to the FBI.
That man's name is also known to this newspaper. He is Shawn
Kenny, the former head of an Aryan Nations chapter in Ohio and a
close associate of ARA bank bandits Peter Langan and Richard Guthrie
(deceased). In fact, Kenny's work for the authorities in the OKBOMB
investigation is mentioned several times in the new documents.
Referring to a number of newspaper articles linking Strassmeir to
others, (whose names and locations at the time were redacted by the
FBI) the Oklahoma City Command Post also lists a number of reasons
why Strassmeir should be located by the FBI and questioned about the
bombing and his alleged long association with McVeigh. Central to
this plea by the OKBOMB case FBI commander is the evidence presented
by this newspaper about Strassmeir and his associates, at Elohim
City and elsewhere.
It is clear in January 1996 that members of the OKBOMB task force
were very agitated about Strassmeir's flight from justice after they
learned the news from an SPLC source.
Dated Jan. 26, 1996, the command post told Freeh and a select
group of other FBI agents the following:
"As Charlotte [FBI office in North Carolina] is aware [name
redacted] is of particular interest to this investigation because of
his association to Elohim City (EC), a paramilitary survivalist
compound located in eastern Oklahoma. McVeigh called the compound on
April 5, 1995.
As indicated in referenced teletype, information has been
received from sources of [name redacted] indicating that [name
redacted] met McVeigh [information redacted] and that McVeigh called
the compound prior to the bombing asking for [name redacted].
"On January 26, 1996, Special Agent SA [name redacted] Mobile
division, Montgomery resident agent advised she had received
additional information from [name redacted] Southern Poverty Law
Center, who advised the following: "He had just obtained information
from a highly reliable source that [name redacted] had fled
[location redacted] about seven days ago. The same source also said
that [information and names redacted].
"Quoting another confidential informant [Kenny] based in
Cincinnati, Ohio said he/she saw [name redacted] at [information
redacted] in [location redacted]. At that time [name redacted (Strassmeir)
said he left Oklahoma because, "things were too hot out there."
Confidential informant clearly understood that [name withheld (Strassmeir)
was referring to the bombing.
Defenbaugh's teletype next set forth a series of questions that
Strassmeir should have to answer, if anyone could find him.
Regardless of the situation and Defenbaugh's pleas for assistance in
the investigation, the Oklahoma City FBI documents do not provide
any evidence that any FBI agent ever went to Berlin to do a
face-to-face interview with the subject of so much pre- and
post-bombing attention by federal agents and informants.
Instead, on April 30 and May 1, 1996, DOJ lawyers Aitman Goelman
and Beth Wilkinson made two conference telephone calls from Denver
to Berlin to interview Strassmeir. An FBI 302 obtained by this
newspaper quite some time ago reveals only the most cursory
interview of the subject, a conversation that Strassmeir later told
a media source "lasted all of about five minutes."
According to the FBI 302, a single FBI agent was allowed to
monitor the call and take notes. What few questions were asked of
Strassmeir were very general in nature and asked only by Wilkinson
and Goelman.
Wilkinson would later make light of Strassmeir's purported
importance to the OKBOMB case by telling Judge Matsch that
Strassmeir was "a mere wisp of wind." She promised the court that
the German was never any interest to OKBOMB investigators.
"We never investigated Strassmeir," she told Matsch during a
pre-trial evidentiary hearing Denver, "so we have nothing to turn
over to Mr. McVeigh's lawyers about him."
Trentadue says he now intends to go back to court for additional
information concerning files the FBI has not yet turned over.
"If the Southern Poverty Law Center was providing information
about Elohim City after the bombing to the FBI, they must have been
providing it before April 19th, Trentadue noted. Asking further: "So
where are those reports?"
Trentadue also says there is considerable information redacted in
these latest reports that clearly should not have been withheld.
"The names of certain newspapers were even withheld," Trentadue
quipped. "Hell, where does the FBI get the right to withhold the
names of the papers it reads?"
OKCSubmariner posted on 2005-08-30 14:59:38 ET Reply Trace
2. To: OKCSubmariner (#1)
Things must be slow at the Island of Misfit Toys, huh?
(grin)
Tell em all Badeye says hello!
Badeye posted on 2005-08-30 15:05:38 ET Reply Trace
3. To: OKCSubmariner (#0)
Sometimes a government will instigate an "outrage" to provide the
cover needed for societal control. This link goes to the Riechstag
Fire history.