27 (In two parts)
Government (pt.
1)
[300 Kilobytes] [about 60
paper pages] Jewish pre-eminence in American government; Jewish economic
influence, especially within the Democratic Party; money control by a
special interest group as the destroyer of true democracy; the dominant
Jewish-Israeli lobbying organization: the
American
Israel Public Action Committee (AIPAC); Jewish lobbying for Israel,
Holocaust-related issues, Jewish immigration to America, and other
ethnocentric concerns.
27
(in two parts)
Government (pt. 2)
[420 Kilobytes]
[about 83 paper pages] Jewish/Zionist domination of the Bill Clinton
administration; the Monica Lewinsky case; Israeli spies in the
American government; Jewish/Israeli influence in governments
throughout the world.
27 (pt. 1)
GOVERNMENT
"Washington is an
easy place to be Jewish these days. There
are some 200,000 Jews living in the area, making this the
seventh-largest Jewish community in North America ... No
one would dispute that area Jews are disproportionately
represented in the upper echelons of law, politics, medicine,
science, journalism, accounting, and other professions."
[The Washington DC Jewish
community includes "at least 62 synagogues"
and "32 Jewish preschool and day schools."]
-- Barbara Matusow,
MAY 2000, p. 79]
"Jewish organizations like to deny that there is such a thing as a
Jewish lobby,
which is, of course, nonsense, but it may fairly be said that the
massive strength
of the Zionist lobby is of comparatively recent origin."
Chaim Bermant, 1977, p. 253
"Oscar Cohen, a long-time official of the Anti-Defamation League,
wrote to a
friend that by the 1970s organized American Jewry had become 'an
agency of
the Israeli government .. follow[ing] its directions from day to
day.'"
-- Peter Novick, 1999, p. 149
"The president of the United States is concerned about our
intelligence. He goes
to the president of Israel and asks him to share the secrets of
Mossad,
the Israeli intelligence agency.
The Israeli president is
unable to help him but suggests
something. He tells the president, 'If you want to know anything,
just go to the
synagogue. The Jews there know everything.' The president dresses up
in a skull
cap, beard, and all the accoutrements of the religious Jew and goes
to a temple.
He sits down next to an old Jew and says, 'What's happening?' The
old Jew says,
'The president is going to be here.'"
-- joke by Jewish comedian Milton Berle, 1996, p. 310
"With money in
hand, you can demand."
--
Old Yiddish folk saying, [KUMOVE, S.,
1985, p. 178]
-- common folk wisdom about any given
political situation
"No election [in modern America],"
says Lenni Brenner, "would be thought complete without the domestic
politicians, down to the ranks of mayors and city council members,
rushing to appear before Jewish organizations to reaffirm their fealty
to 'the only democracy in the Middle East.'" [BRENNER, p. 9] "While some
Jewish agencies have persistently denied the existence of a Jewish
vote," says Stephen Isaacs, "just as persistently the politicians have
pandered specifically to 'Jewish' interests and issues. The pandering
has been especially observable since 1948, when the state of Israel was
created." [ISAACS, p. 142]
"The percentage of Jews ... who
involve themselves in party affairs as policy-makers and fund-raisers,"
noted Will Maslow, general counsel of the American Jewish Congress, "is
probably higher than any other racial, religious, or ethnic group. The
result is that Jews play a role in the political life of the country
whose significance far transcends their proportion of the total
population." [BRENNER, p. 121] There are, suggested the 1999 Jewish
Democratic Council executive director, Ira Foreman, a "disproportionate
number of opinion leaders among Jews." [ROTH, B., 10-11-99] Jewish
theologian and political activist Seymour Siegel suggested that the
"messianic drive is present in many great Jews. Having lost the faith
that there is a God, but not wanting to give up messianism, they go into
politics ..." [ISAACS, p. 20] "The pursuit of salvation through
politics is a modern disease," wrote Norman Podhoretz, "And a lot of
Jews are infected with it." [ISAACS, p. 26]
"American Jewry cannot claim the
dubious distinction of being normal," notes Henry Feingold, "It is, to
be sure, shaped by the American society with which it casts its lot; but
it also has, as part of it, Jewish connections, a long separate history
of its own that shapes its vision. It lives delicately suspended between
two cultural pulls, the Jewish and the American. It's that connection to
k'lal Yisrael, the mysterious tie that binds Jews everywhere
together, and that also determines its unique political character ... It
is also that connection that compels American Jewry to exert a special
effort to influence the United States government ... United States
foreign policy contains the most discernible signs of a specific Jewish
influence." [FEINGOLD, p. 115] Jewish influence in American popular
culture and government is so great that sociologist Irving Horowitz even
felt comfortable asserting that "the critique of American imperialism,
reformism, and welfareism readily spills into a critique of America's
Jewish element." [HOROWITZ, I., p. 91]
So what is the main Jewish concern in
high level American politics? Crime? Pollution? The unemployment rolls?
The economy? Racism? "In the world of big-league Jewish politics," noted
the Baltimore Jewish Times in 1996, "one question overshadows all
others, year after year: how friendly is the current [White House]
administration of Jewish and pro-Israel interests? Jewish leaders may be
interested in a host of domestic and international issues. But in the
end, an unfriendly administration, or one that sends mixed signals,
becomes the central organizing principle of Jewish political life."
[BESSER [LOVE], p. 34]
"[Israel supporters'] influence,"
wrote former United States Congressman Paul Findley in the 1980s, "is
pervasive throughout the government and in almost every aspect of life,
private and public, across the United States." [FINDLEY, p. xxvi]
Behind the scenes Jewish American political and economic lobbying for
governmental concessions to Jewish concerns has a long history. In 1906,
for example, financier Jacob Schiff and other wealthy Jews formed
the American Jewish Committee, initially to help fellow Jews across the
world in Russia. One way to accomplish this was to put severe economic
pressure on the Tsar's economy. American President Taft, however, was
not receptive to Jewish demands for an abrogation of the Russo-American
trade treaty. "Calling upon friends and resources," says Edwin Black,
"the [Jewish] Committee began a widespread public appeal to have
Congress force the President to end commercial relations with Russia.
Within weeks, House and Senate abrogation resolutions -- each personally
approved by the Committee -- were prepared." [BLACK, p. 31] The
rescinding of the treaty passed in a vote shortly thereafter.
Powerful financier Bernard Baruch
(whose father was a South Carolina member of the Ku Klux Klan) [COIT,
M., p. 12-13] was head of President Woodrow Wilson's War
Industries Board during World War I. [PLESUR, M. 1982, p. 86] A 1957
dust jacket blurb for his biography notes that "for nearly fifty years
Bernard M. Baruch has been almost as well known to most Americans
as that of the President of the United States, and yet he has never held
an elective office ... Mr. Baruch is best known in the role of
'adviser' not only to six Presidents, but to Cabinet members,
congressmen, generals, diplomats and party leaders ... As Chairman of
the War Industries Board in the First World War, he controlled the
entire industrial establishment of the country." [COIT, M., 1957]
Jeffrey Potter notes his influence in the Franklin D. Roosevelt
administration, when, in 1944, the President fell ill:
"The condition was serious enough for him to go to Bernie
Baruch's plantation,
Hobcaw, in South Carolina, for
recuperation. FDR didn't really
like his host, [Jewish media mogul] Dorothy [Schiff]
explained, as both he and
Eleanor thought Baruch too conservative,
but he was a source of campaign
funding." [POTTER, J., 1976, p.
194] (Schiff was also an influential friend of
Roosevelt: "By the
time Dorothy visited [Roosevelt] at Warm Springs,
Georgia, a few weeks before Christmas, 1938, she no longer felt
ill at ease.
As usual, she had to make her own travel arrangement, and it never
occurred
to her to wonder why it wasn't done for her. She now suspects
[Roosevelt]
was afraid to have it known that it was always at his invitation
that they met.")
[POTTER, J., 1976, p. 155]
Another such case is that of Jewish Supreme Court Justice Louis
Brandeis, "one of [President Woodrow] Wilson's key advisers."
[MURPHY, B., 1983, p. 27] "After meeting with Jacob de Haas, a
former secretary to [Zionist leader] Theodore Herzl in 1912,"
notes current Jewish Supreme Court Justice Stephen Breyer,
"[Brandeis] joined the American Federation of Zionists and started
making public remarks in support of Zionism ... In 1917 ... his
intervention with President Wilson helped secure American support for
the Balfour Declaration [in support of a Jewish state in Palestine],
thereby assuring its issuance. In 1938, not long before his death, he
called upon President Roosevelt, seeking FDR's public diplomatic support
for allowing more Jewish refugees to travel to Palestine." [BREYER, p.
18] [De Haas actually became Brandeis's secretary.]
[MURPHY, B., 1983, p. 26] "Since Brandeis," notes Kevin Avruch
about the Zionist currents in American government, "the Zionist movement
in America functioned effectively as banker for the world [Zionist]
movement and as a fulcrum for the political leverage sometimes needed
to mobilize American presidents and public opinion in support of the
Jewish cause." [AVRUCH, K., 1981, p. 32] "
By 1956, American Secretary of State
John Foster Dulles complained that "I am aware of how almost impossible
it is in this country to carry out a foreign policy not approved by the
Jews." [SORIN, p. 216] On another occasion, long before Jews had built
their modern political machine, he complained about the "terrific
control the Jews have over the news media and the barrage which the Jews
have built up on Congressmen ... I am very much concerned over the fact
that the Jewish influence here is completely dominating the scene and
making it almost impossible to get Congress to do anything they don't
approve of. The Israeli Embassy is practically dictating to Congress
through influential Jewish people in the country." [FINDLEY, DEL, p.
105]
In 1984, Admiral Thomas Moorer,
former Chairman of the Joint Chiefs of Staff, complained that
"I've never seen a President -- I
don't care who he is -- stand up to [the
Jews] ... They always get what they
want. The Israelis know what is
going on all the time. I got to the
point where I wouldn't write anything
down. If the American people
understood what a grip these people
have got on our government, they
would rise up in arms." [CURTISS,
p. 267]
Another former Chairman of the Joint
Chiefs of Staff, General George J. Brown, told an audience at Duke
University that "[the Jewish lobby] is so strong you wouldn't believe
now. We have the Israelis coming to us for equipment. We say we can't
possibly get the Congress to support that. They say, 'Don't worry about
the Congress.' This is somebody from another country, but they can do
it." [CURTISS, p. 267] Brown's comments almost cost him his job when
Jewish lobbying groups attacked him with charges of anti-Semitism.
A distinction must be made, wrote
Republican Senator Charles Matthias, "between ethnicity, which enriches
American life and culture, and organized ethnic interest groups, which
sometimes press causes that derogate from the national interest."
American elected politicians, adds the senator, "have been subjected to
recurrent pressures from what has come to be known as the Israel lobby."
[BLITZER, p. 134]
"During the 1944 presidential
campaign," notes Steven Spiegel, "[Franklin D.] Roosevelt was pressured
into promising to work for the establishment of Palestine as a free and
democratic Jewish commonwealth [i.e., modern Israel]." [SPIEGEL, S.,
p. 12] "There were so many Jews in Roosevelt's advisory entourage --
Samuel Rosenman, Benjamin Cohen, Felix Frankfurter,
David Lilienthal, Bernard Baruch, Anne Rosenberg,
Sidney Hillman, and David Niles," says Jewish scholar Barnet
Litvinoff, "as well [Louis] Brandeis, [Henry]
Morgenthau [Roosevelt's Secretary of Treasury from 1933-45], and [Herbert]
Lehman [the governor of New York] -- that many people believed
that the President himself must be descended from German Jews."
[LITVINOFF, S., p. 41] ("During the war, Republican campaigners,
referring to Roosevelt's prominent Jewish associate Sidney Hillman,
put up billboards across the nation: 'It's Your Country-- Why Let Sidney
Hillman Run It?") [NOVICK, P., 1999, p. 42] "David Lilienthal was
chosen by Roosevelt to direct the Tennessee Valley Authority, an agency
that virtually reshaped the role of government toward business. Later,
he was also chairman of the Atomic Energy Commission." [PLESUR, M.,
1982, p. 142]
At least three of Roosevelt's "Palace Guard", reputedly his seven
"most intimate advisers," were Jewish (Frankfurter, Niles,
and Rosenman). [MURPHY, B., 1983, p. 257] Rosenman was an
official Roosevelt speechwriter; Frankfurter, a Supreme Court
justice, was an unofficial one. The judge also "gradually advanced
himself till he was virtually an informal campaign manager [of
Roosevelt's presidential campaign], playing a central role in every
aspect of the campaign, from drafting speeches to plotting election
strategy. [MURPHY, B., 1983, p. 194-195, 205] "Roosevelt surrounded
himself with so many unmistakably Jewish advisers," notes Barbara
Matusow, "that his enemies took to branding his programs the 'Jew
Deal.'" [MATUSOW, B., MAY 2000, p. 79] "During the Roosevelt
presidency," notes Doris Kearns Goodwin, "though Jews constituted only 3
percent of the U.S. population, they represented nearly 15 percent of
Roosevelt's top appointments. Indeed, so prominent were Jews in the
Roosevelt administration that bigots routinely referred to the New Deal
as the Jew Deal and charged that Roosevelt was himself a Jew."
[GOODWIN, D.K., 1995, p. 102] Leo Rosten was a "popular Jewish
writer" and head of the Office of War Information's 'Nature of the
Enemy' department. [NOVICK, P., 1999, p. 27] In 1943, William Bullitt, a
former ambassador was complaining that "the Roosevelt administration's
emphasis on the European war as opposed to the Asian one was the result
of Jewish influence." [NOVICK, P., 1999, p. 28]
Roosevelt himself once joked, when
running into Samuel Rosenman, Stephen Wise (a rabbi and
World Zionist Organization president) and Nahum Goldmann (who
succeeded Wise in the Zionist group) outside his weekend home in the
country (where Rosenman rented a home nearby): "Carry on, boys,
Sam will tell me what to do on Monday ... Imagine what [Nazi
leader] Goebbels would pay for a photo of this scene: the President of
the United States taking his instructions from the three Elders of
Zion." [GOLDMANN, N., 1978, p. 156] (Decades earlier, President
Theodore Roosevelt's Jewish circle included Oscar Solomon
Strauss, the Secretary of Commerce and Labor who declined an offer
to become the country's Secretary of Treasury. "He was afraid," says the
director of the American Jewish Historical Society, Michael Feldman,
"too close an association of Jews and money would be bad for the image
of the Jew." [LIEBLICH, J., 8-19-2000, p. A10] Earlier there was
Julius Rosenwald, the Sears-Roebuck mogul: "An unabashed admirer of
the solid conservatism of William Howard Taft, and one of his most loyal
supporters within the Jewish community, Rosenwald contributed
generously to the campaigns of every Republican candidate of his era. He
was an especially ardent backer of his friend Herbert Hoover,
contributing $50,000 to Hoover's 1928 presidential campaign and becoming
a close adviser and confidant during his presidency.") [DALIN, D., 1998]
Close to Hoover was also Lewis Strauss, Hoover's "private
secretary" and "lifelong friend and trusted confidant." "Strauss'
volunteer job would not only start a lifelong friendship with Hoover but
also open up channels of cooperation and amity between Hoover and
leading members of the jewish community." [WENTLING, S., 2000, p. 377,
382] "In March 1919, as the feast of Passover approached, Hoover was
asked to ensure that the Jews of Poland received flour in time to make
Passover bread. The chief readily complied." [WENTLING, S., 2000, p.
383]
As early as the 1940s, Zionist
propaganda to move American foreign policy to Zionist dictates was
massively orchestrated. As Melvin Urofsky notes
"Zionist groups organized massive
petition and letter-writing campaigns.
President Roosevelt received one such
petition in January 1945
seconding the Biltmore program
[favorable policy to the Jews in then-
Palestine] and signed by more than
150 college presidents and deans
and 1,800 faculty members drawn from
250 colleges and universities
in 45 states. A total of 41 state
legislatures and hundreds of municipalities,
representing more than 90 per cent of
the nation's population, approved
pro-Zionist resolutions." [UROFSKY,
M., 1978, p. 34] )
Roosevelt was, of course, a Democrat.
From the Republican Zionist side against Roosevelt, Arthur Hertzberg
notes the case of Rabbi Abba Hillel Silver, president of the
Central Conference of American Rabbis:
"[Silver] remained a factor
in Republican politics, because he could
and did produce the necessary Jewish
votes in Ohio, especially
for his friends in the [politician]
Taft family. As a Zionist leader he
translated this power into political
leverage against Franklin Delano
Roosevelt, when the latter faltered
on Zionist issues." [NEUSNER,
J., 1972, p. 40]
In the next American presidency,
notes Steven Spiegel, "it is astonishing that [President Truman] was not
more pro-Zionist, given the pressures on him ... [SPIEGEL, S., p. 16]
... Truman was often bitter about the Zionist pressures on him. 'If
Jesus Christ couldn't satisfy them here on earth,' he is reported to
have exclaimed, 'how the hell am I supposed to?'" [SPIEGEL, S., p. 20]
Under Truman, a Jewish White House officer, David Niles, "was
strongly committed to the Zionist cause; he was not only prepared to
argue with the President in favor of a Jewish state but to counter the
effects of the [White House] bureaucracy ... [SPIEGEL, S., p. 17] ... [Niles']
modus operandi seems to have been to act for the president as long as
Truman had not ordered him against a particular action ... Truman does
not seem to have known precisely what Niles was doing." [SPIEGEL,
S., p. 29]
"Our great stroke of luck," wrote
World Zionist Organization president Nahum Goldmann, "was that Roosevelt
was replaced by Harry Truman ... He said: 'My friends are Jews, the Jews
want partition [in Palestine], all right, they can have it' ... The
president had a Jewish childhood friend called Jacobson, his
co-partner in a shop before we went into politics, and it is partly due
to this man that we got the Negev [desert as part of modern Israel]." [GOLDMANN,
N., 1978, p. 33] Eddie Jacobson, member of a B'nai B'rith lodge
in Kansas City, flew to Washington DC to expressly implore Truman to see
Zionist leader Chaim Weizmann. As Melvin Urofsky notes:
"Although Truman was always glad to
see old friends, as soon as
Jacobson started talking about
Palestine, the President tensed and
said that he would rather not discuss
the subject, letting the whole
problem run its course in the United
Nations. But Jacobson, by
now very self-conscious, would not
stop, even when Truman
started complaining about 'how
disrespectful and how mean' some
of the Jewish spokesmen had been."
[UROFSKY, 1978, p. 165]
Theo Thackery, the non-Jewish husband of Dorothy Schiff (then-owner
of the New York Post and granddaughter of famous Jewish
investment banker Jacob Schiff), explains an incident he had with
President Harry Truman in the White House:
"Almost immediately in the conversation [Truman] said, 'Now
Thackery,
if only the goddamn New York Jews would just shut their goddamn
mouths
and quit hollering ... They're screwing up the situation, and I
could get along
with them, if they would just get together and decide what the
hell they
want. They're all over the lot, the goddamn Jews, and here you
are, not
even a Jew, representing the spearhead that's causing all kinds of
hell.'
I had to say, 'Well, Mr. President, you make it impossible for me
to
continue this conversation. I've got to assume by 'goddamn New
York
Jews' you must mean my wife, who is a Jew. I know you better than
to
believe that you are consciously anti-Semitic, but I consider it
absolutely
outrageous.' Immediately, I went to his press secretary
and the chairman
of the Democratic National Committee. I told them I'd had this
absolutely
terrible conversation with the President and suggested he be
advised more
clearly on such matters.'" [POTTER, J., 1976, p.
202-203]
Melvin Urofsky notes the successful
Zionist pressures upon American government towards the founding of the
modern Jewish state of Israel (in 1948):
"Edwin M. Wright has charged that
'the Zionist propaganda machine
was efficient and thorough,
blanketing the American political processes
in systematic campaigns targeted at
the general population, city halls,
state houses, and on up the ladder to
Washington.' A study of American
periodical coverage of the Palestine
debate confirmed that the Zionist
viewpoint dominated the medium, with
an emphasis on the humanitarian
and religious aspects of the
movement. Recent studies of Harry
Truman's role in the pro-partition [of
Arabs and Jews in then-Palestine]
decision agree that Zionist-generated
political pressure proved
the major factor in the White House
overruling State Department advice,
a conclusion James Forrestal [the
Secretary of Defense] bitterly reached
thirty years ago." [UROFSKY, M.,
1978, p. 147]
Behind the scenes Zionist lobbying
for special favors swayed FBI director J. Edgar Hoover (he turned a
blind eye to Jews smuggling arms out of the U.S. to the Jewish army in
Palestine), [UROFSKY, M., 1978, p. 157] and New York City mayor William
O'Dwyer (who arranged for policeman to abandon guard of a Zionist cache
of weapons headed also to the Middle East.) [UROFSKY, p. 157]
In recent decades, President Dwight
D. Eisenhower in the 1950s best resisted Jewish lobbying pressures. As
Melvin Urofsky notes,
"The first five years of the
Eisenhower administration ...
marked the low point in relations
between the Israeli and American
governments. One analyst has
suggested that Eisenhower, as the
only President from Truman to Ford
who did not serve in Congress,
had never been exposed to Jewish
political pressure. Eisenhower's
military career had shielded him from
this experience, and of all
recent Presidents, he showed, the
least inclination to befriend the
Jewish community." [UROFSKY, M.,
1978, p. 305]
During Eisenhower's administration,
in 1956, in a secret plan devised with France and Great Britain (both
which had interests in the Suez Canal), Israel -- in an act in direct
contradiction to American foreign policy interests -- invaded Egypt's
Sinai desert. Then, despite Eisenhower administration and United Nations
insistence that Israel withdraw from the territory it had seized, the
Jewish army remained. Urofsky notes the American Jewish mood of the
period and its efforts to dictate American foreign policy:
"Although American Jews agonized
over Israeli intransigence, they
did not worry about the old charge
of dual loyalty. Here was the classic
case that the anti-Zionists of the
American Council for Judaism [a now
extinct Jewish anti-Zionist group]
had so fearfully predicted: a clash of
policies between the United States
and Israel, with American Jews
caught in the middle. What would
they do? They bombarded Congress
and the White House with demands and
protests that the Eisenhower
administration pursue a more
pro-Israel course. Some experts believed
that American Jews would hesitate
before contributing -- even indirectly
-- to a nation at odds with their
own. Yet just the opposite happened.
UJA contributions jumped 20 per
cent, from $58.8 million to $70.6
million." [UROFSKY, M., 1978, p.
315]
Eisenhower was an exception in his
resistance to incessant Jewish pressures. What has increasingly
developed over recent decades in American government, much more the
governmental norm, was bluntly addressed on June 6, 1972, by a troubled
U.S. citizen, Norman F. Dacey, of Southburg, Connecticut, who bought a
full page ad in the New York Times to state his perception that
the United States had become "a dancing bear, responding dumbly to the
commands given by the government of Israel and indirectly through a
potent fifth column which operates here in America and which gives blind
obedience to the Zionist credo that all Jews everywhere owe national
loyalty to Israel." The Jewish community responded to Dacey's ad with
outrage; the Anti-Defamation League even bought Times space for a
rebuttal. In the midst of a unified Jewish attack against the Times
for allowing such an ad, the Jewish vice-president of the paper,
Sydney Grenson, formally apologized to the ADL for printing the
critical ad, saying that the Times was "trying to work out a
policy with the Advertising Acceptability Department to make sure that
even the barest chance of such an implication for any ethnic group
should not appear in the paper." [FORSTER/EPSTEIN, p. 120-121]
Jewish influence in (and upon)
government is extraordinary. In the spring of 1977, for instance,
Congress passed a bill that prohibited American corporations from
complying with the ongoing Arab economic boycott against Israel. "The
bill was hammered out between Jewish defense agencies and the Business
Council, a prestigious, high-powered big business organization headed by
Du Pont's chairman, Irving Shapiro." [KREFETZ, p. 92] "The
pro-Israeli banks were so dominant in the field," said Business Week,
that they 'cannot realistically be avoided because of their sheer size."
[KREFETZ, p. 98] "The domestic political game played around the
activities of the United States in the Middle East has only one major
player," says Seymour Lipset, "the organized Jewish community who, with
campaign contributions, activism, and media influence, constitute a
major force." [LIPSET, p. 157]
In November 2001, during the chaotic Palestinian Intifada
(uprising) against Israeli occupation and international outcry against
repeatedly bloody Israeli invasions of Palestinian towns and territory
(let alone Israeli campaigns of "targeted assassinations"), 89 U. S.
Senators wrote a formal letter to President George W. Bush and "urged
him not to restrain Israel from retaliating fully against Palestinian
violence and to express his solidarity with Israel soon." "There is
constant concern about the administration's wavering," declared Jewish
Senator Arlen Specter, "[Secretary of State Colin] Powell talks about
the cycle of violence that suggests one produces the other and that there
is a moral equivalency, which is not true. Terrorists killing civilians
is totally unjustified, and Israel's response is self-defense."
[SCIOLINO, E., 11-17-01]
This focus on Jewish international
concerns in United States governmental actions, even aside from Israel,
often overrules American ones. "In 1979," says Jewish scholar Stephen
Whitfield, " ... the FBI had arrested two Soviet spies operating on
American soil. The spies were exchanged not for Americans in Soviet
custody but for five Soviet nationals who were political prisoners,
including two Jews convicted .... nine years earlier. For American
diplomacy to consider the lives of non-American citizens so precious was
a pointed contrast to its failures before and during the Holocaust."
[WHITFIELD, American, p. 16] In 1986, a Jew, Karl Koecher
"one of the most important [Soviet] spies in United States history" was
released from an American prison in exchange -- not for an American, but
-- for Soviet dissident Anatoly Acharansky who then moved to
Israel and later became the Jewish state's Minister of Trade to
capitalist Russia. [DEUTSCHE PRESSE AGENTUR, 1-26-97; KESSLER, R.,
9-17-98, p. C1]
In 1973 the Jewish Secretary of
State, Henry Kissinger, "convinced the Soviets that Jewish
emigration was a necessary price for winning ... coveted trade
benefits." [GOLDBERG, JJ, p. 171] "In 1975," notes Menachem Kaufman,
"when President Ford and Secretary Kissinger were unable to convince the
Rabin government [in Israel] to withdraw from the Mitla and Gidi Passes
in Sinai without a formal renunciation of belligerency by the Egyptians,
the Ford administration placed a partial curb on U.S. military and
financial support for Israel. American Jewish reaction was a nationwide
campaign of support for Israel." [KAUFMAN, p. 247] In May 1977 Congress
passed an anti-boycott bill against the unified Arab economic war
against the Jewish state. "The Jewish organizations," notes J. J.
Goldberg, "had worked together more or less seamlessly, securing the
cooperation of friendly Jews in the news media, business, the
administration, and Congress. The result was a major change in United
States policy." [GOLDBERG, JJ, p. 171]
Prominent (Jewish) CBS television
newsman Mike Wallace wrote about the Jewish lobby that heavily leaned on
the media, and him, in 1975:
"At that time the so-called Jewish
lobby was one of the most powerful
pressure groups in America. That is
no slur but a simple statement
of fact. It was organized,
well-financed and extremely savvy, especially
when it came to dealing with the
media. According to The Power
Peddlers,
a book published in 1977 about the effect of lobbying
activities in the United States, 'The
Israeli lobby is unique among
lobby groups with its 'clout' with
the press. [No other lobby] has
succeeded in making reporters look
over their shoulders as much as
the Israeli lobby.'" [WALLACE/GATES,
1984, p. 286-287]
Jewish influence in the American
government is well-known in political circles throughout the world. In
2000, the Jewish Telegraphic Agency reported on this phenomenon,
in an article entitled Nations See Jews as Key to Winning with U. S.
:
"Why U. S. Jews want to meet with world leaders is clear and well
known.
The focal point of most of these meetings is Israel and how the
Jewish
state can strengthen alliances around the world. Why world leaders
want
to meet with Jews is more interesting, less publicized, and to some
Jews,
discomfiting. These leaders believe in Jewish power ... In fact,
Jewish
leaders nowadays receive mostly red-carpet treatment. They have
access to the corridors of power in most capitals around the world
...
American Jewish leaders explain all this buttering up in
euphemistic
terms, suggesting that foreigners have a fascination ' with or
'appreciation'
for American Jews. But when pressed, Jewish leaders admit the true
driving
force behind it is the lingering belief that Jews are capable of
making or
breaking relations with the United States and capable of wrecking
havoc
on the world's financial markets." [JORDAN, M., 9-13-00]
Per the Jewish state, by 1994, wrote Benjamin Ginsberg, "that
fully three-fourths of America's foreign aid budget is devoted to
Israeli security interests is a tribute in considerable measure to the
lobbying prowess of AIPAC [the American Israel Public Action Committee]
and the importance of the Jewish community in American politics."
[GINZBURG, p. 2] "Each year the United States Congress donates to Israel
the equivalent of $1,000 for every Israeli man, woman, and child,"
complained former Congressman Paul Findley, "No matter how sharply
Congress cuts other items in the Federal budget, gifts to Israel sweep
through without restrictive amendment or murmur of opposition. My years
on Capitol Hill led me to conclude that aid to Israel is more sacrosanct
there than even social security or Medicaid." [FINDLEY, p. xxvii ] ...
Since 1987 direct economic and military aid to Israel has annually
totaled $3 billion or more. In addition, financial arrangements worked
out solely for Israel bring the total to about $5 billion a year ...
[FINDLEY, p. 110] "The magnitude of United States support for Israel,"
notes Cheryl Rubenberg, "-- militarily, politically, economically, and
diplomatically -- goes beyond any traditional relationship between
states in the international system." [FINDLEY, DEL, p. 111] "By the late
1980s," notes Glenn Frankel, "Israel was not only receiving more United
States foreign aid than any other country, but also getting it at more
favorable terms than anyone else. While other countries received their
economic aid in quarterly installments, Israel got its aid in a lump sum
at the beginning of the year, allowing the Israelis to make an extra $75
million in 1991 by investing in United States Treasury bills." [FRANKEL,
p. 223] In the 1990s, when the 104th Congress "slashed nearly all other
foreign assistance," Israel got its regular $3 billion. [BLOOMFIELD, D,
Election, p. 52]
"More than one-third of United
States world-wide aid," notes Richard Curtiss, a former career foreign
service officer, "has gone annually to one of the smallest and least
populous countries on earth.' [CURTISS, p. 2] The total amount of U.S.
taxpayer aid to Israel since 1949 totals well over $83 billion -- a
value of $14,346 for every single present Israeli. [CURTISS, p. 4] In
addition, notes Curtiss, "fueled by the unique U.S. law that grants U.S.
tax exemption to donations from the U.S. to any Israeli institution that
is exempt from Israeli taxes, the total of tax-exempt [private] U.S.
donations to Israel now approaches $1 billion annually." [CURTISS, p.
6] (Israel and the worldwide Jewish lobby has even managed a deep
cash-flow from Holocaust guilt-ridden Germany. Since World War II,
Germany has paid $95.64 billion in restitution payments to mostly Jews
worldwide, "of which approximately $26 billion has gone to individual
recipients in Israel or the state of Israel itself." [CURTISS, p. 8] )
While Israel regularly gets its huge sums, the neglect of other nations
is breathtaking. A Washington Post commentator noted in 1999 that
"the United States ranks last among developed nations in percentage of
resources devoted to foreign aid." [OVERHOLSER, G., p. 7]
Jane Adas notes that
"All the funding for the National
Endowment for the Arts since its
creation in 1966 amounts to less
than eight months of aid to Israel;
the $10 million cut in funding for
PBS equals 16 hours of aid to
Israel; in 1996 cuts in programs for
America's poor totaled $5.7
billion, cuts in aid to Israel were
zero, aid to Israel was $5.5 billion."
[APAS, p. 106]
Among the results of the gigantic
American welfare program for Israel (and its subsequent welfare
programs) is that noted by Israeli scholar Menachem Friedman: "The
establishment of the state of Israel as a western welfare state created
nearly ideal economic and social conditions for the flourishing of
special Haredi [ultra-Orthodox] educational institutions." [FRIEDMAN,
M., p. 185]
And Israel's repayment for such
phenomenal aid? In 1999, even ardent pro-Israeli (and Jewish) columnist
William Safire was aghast at Israel's installing of aerial
reconnaissance radar on Chinese planes. Worth hundreds of millions of
dollars to the Jewish state, Safire said the deal reflected "Israel's
amoral policy." "This flies in the face of U.S. security interest," he
wrote,
"... American forces will be directly
threatened by Chinese air, naval
and missile forces emboldened by
Israel's Phalcon battle management
... Though candidates for U.S.
President today are fearful of raising
this question, American supporters of
Israel want to know if Israel tips
the technological balance against a
democratic American ally in Asia
[Taiwan], why should the United States
guarantee that Israel continue
to have a 'qualitative edge' in the
Middle East?" [SAFIRE, W., 12-25-99]
In 1995, Duncan Clarke, professor of international relations and
coordinator of the United States Foreign Policy field at American
University, addressed the threat to America of widespread Israeli resale
of American weapons systems:
"Other countries have been caught evading U.S. re-export controls,
but
Israel's case appears unique. Not only is it the beneficiary of
massive
U.S. support, but it is also by far the principal offender and
foremost
concern of U.S. officials responsible for implementing the laws on
re-export of U.S. defense products. Unauthorized Israeli
re-transfers
of U.S. defense items and technology are of particular concern for
several reasons, say U.S. officials: Israel re-exports much more
often
than do other allies and with more sensitive technology; it sells
to 'pariah'
states with which the United States refuses to deal; its
sophisticated
defense industry makes retransfers harder to track than other arms
exporters; and its retransfers are generally governmentally
sanctioned
and not simply the result of a wayward company, as is usually the
case
elsewhere. Israel's unauthorized retransfer of U.S. defense products
is
part of a larger pattern of illicit behavior that includes
diversions of U.S.
military aid, industrial espionage, and improper end use of U.S.
military equipment. Israel often retransfers U.S. defense products
to
states that are potentially hostile to the United States or are
blatant
violators of human rights. These retransfers have threatened
American
commercial interests, compromised intelligence, upset regional
stability,
strained diplomatic relations, and confirmed the U.S. national
security
bureaucracy's long-standing distrust of Israeli technology transfer
practices." [CLARKE, D., 1995, p. 89-90]
Israeli weapons retransfers include versions of the U.S. Sidewinder
missile, aerial refueling systems, the Popeye missile, the Star cruise
missile, the Arrow missile, thermal imaging tank sights, space launch
vehicles, and jet fighters. [CLARKE, D., 1995, p. 104-107] What kind of
country are we apparently dealing with here? "Israel," adds Clarke,
"engages in unauthorized defense re-exports largely to nourish its
economy's
large defense sector and because it is confident, for good reason,
that Washington
will not or cannot enforce the law. Indeed, the Clinton
administration relaxed curbs
on the transfer of sensitive technology to Israel despite Israel's
dismal record
of unauthorized transfers. There has been a persistent
pattern of misconduct ...
Israeli scholar Ehud Sprinzak holds that his society is afflicted
with an 'elite
illegalism' that is central to the country's domestic political
culture and
international behavior ... [E]lite illegalism deprecates the idea
of the rule of law
and assumes 'that democracy can work without a strict adherence to
law,'
as Sprinzak writes. He asserts that past leaders like Moshe Dayan
(a 'sovereign
personality' above the law) were role models for a generation of
IDF officers."
[CLARKE, D., 1995, p. 108-109]
In 2001, an Israeli newspaper noted that the United States might
literally become a parking lot for Israeli weapons:
"Israel has asked the United States to permanently base some
Israeli fighter
jets at a U.S. Air Force in America for combat training of Israeli
pilot, officials
of the two countries said Wednesday." [HAARETZ, 8-2-02]
"Because the security and welfare of
Israel are so pivotal to Jewish destiny," says Jewish scholar Stephen
Whitfield, "and to the future of the Jewish people everywhere else,
pro-Zionism has become the prerequisite for the practice of Jewish
politics in America." [WHITFIELD, p. 103] Jewish members of the 99th
United States Congress included eight seats in the Senate and 29 in the
House of Representatives. By this time Jews had also chaired the Council
of Economic Development, the Federal Reserve Board, the National
Security Council, as well as headed the Department of Defense and the
American delegation to the United Nations. [WHITFIELD, p. 92] By 1996,
slowly -- but ever -- increasing, 10 of the 100 U.S. Senators were
Jewish (over representing their population percentage by 400%). By 1998
the number was 11. In the House of Representatives, before the
Republicans gained control of that body,
33 seats were
Jewish-held, 7.5% of the House, [GOLDBERG, JJ, Bagels, p. 13]
more than a 300% overrepresentation of the Jewish population in America.
Among these Jewish Congress members was Marjorie Margolies-Mezvinsky,
a former reporter for NBC. Prominent 1970s-era New York Congresswoman
Bella Abzug was probably not atypical in her political perspective when
she declared: "Ever since my youth I've been a Zionist, and I've worked
hard for the cause of Jewish homeland too. I've visited Israel and I've
raised my kids with a very strong background in Jewish culture. Besides
that, I spent a couple of years of my life as a Hebrew teacher!" [ABZUG,
B., 1972, p. 70]
In 2001, the (Jewish) Forward noted the situation for
Jewish influence in the now Democratically-controlled Senate (thanks to
a defection by a Republican senator to the Democratic side):
"Nothing symbolized the prospect of increased access more clearly
than one stark
demographic statistic: The 50 Democrats who make up the Senate's
new majority
caucus will include nine Jewish members, just shy of one-fifth.
The Republican
caucus includes just a single Jewish member, Arlen Specter
of Pennsylvania. Some
of those Jewish Democrats will hold positions of crucial
importance to Jewish
activists when the Senate changes hands. Senator Carl Levin
of Michigan is slated
to chair the Senate Armed Services Committee, which oversees
crucial areas of
U.S.-Israeli military cooperation. Senator Dianne Feinstein
and Senator Barbara
Boxer, both of California, will chair the subcommittees
dealing with domestic and
international terrorism respectively on
the Judiciary and Foreign Relations committees.
Most observers
expected little in the way of a shakeup in Middle East policy following
the shift. 'We don't expect much of a change,' said Ken Bricker,
spokesman of
the American Israel Public Affairs Committee, the leading
pro-Israel lobby. 'That's
one of the benefits of being an organization that places so much
emphasis on
bipartisanship.'" [DONADIO/SCHWARTZ, 6-1-00]
By the 1970s and 1980s more and more
Jews were highly visible in positions of great political power in
government. At the local level, mayors of New York City (Ed Koch);
Atlanta (Sam Massell); Kansas City (Richard Berkeley);
Omaha; and San Francisco (Diane Feinstein) were Jewish. Jewish
mayors with tenures in the late 1980s and 1990s (some into the new
century) included those of San Diego (Susan Golding);
Indianapolis (Stephen Goldsmith); Dallas, Texas (Annette
Strauss); San Jose (hub of California's hi-tech Silicon Valley:
Susan Hammer); Portland, Oregon (Vera Katz); Las Vegas (Oscar
Goodman); St. Paul, Minnesota (Norm Coleman); Louisville,
Kentucky (Jerry Abramson); Tucson, Arizona (George Miller);
Virginia Beach, Virginia (Meyer Orbendorf); Toronto, Canada (Mel
Lastman); Prescott, Arizona (Sam Steiger); and Ottawa, Canada
(Jacquelin Holzman). Linda Lingle was also the "mayor" of
Maui County in Hawaii for a time in the same era. Even the ceremonial
Lord Mayor of London, England, is Jewish: Peter Levene. Much
earlier in his career, controversial TV talk show host Jerry Springer
was the mayor Cincinnati. [JEWHOO, 2000] Even the mayor of Fargo,
North Dakota, was Jewish in the 1970s. [GOLDEN, H., 1973, p. 6]
In Massachusetts, The Jewish Advocate noted in 1994 that
"[the Boston-area town of] Chelsea's former mayor, Joe Pressman
-- also a Jew -- was indicted for corruption shortly after the city was
taken into receivership." [SINERT, M., 12-22-94, p. 1]
Jewish state governors over the years
have included those of Oregon (Neil Goldschmidt), Madeline May
Kunin (Vermont), Rhode Island (Frank Licht and Bruce
Sundlun), Connecticut (Abraham Ribicoff: also Secretary of
Health, Education, and Welfare under John F. Kennedy), and New Mexico (Arthur
Seligman). David Barrett served a term as the premier of
Canada's British Columbia in the 1970s. [JEWHOO, 2000] In 1977, the
Jewish governor of Maryland, Marvin Mandel, and four others were
"convicted of conspiracy to have the Governor influence race track
legislation in return for $380,000 in bribes." [AYRES, B.D., p. A1]
(Shortly thereafter, in 1982, another Maryland Jewish politician was
sentenced to prison. Baltimore City Council President Walter Orlinsky
pleaded guilty to "one count of extortion ... [He also] conceded that
the Government could prove other charges against him.") [NYT, 9-23-82,
p. A24] [BALTMORE JEWISH TIMES, 1-23-98, p. 8]
Kenneth Duberstein was Chief
of Staff to the President from 1988-89. Philip Klutznik was
President Jimmy Carter's Secretary of Commerce. He was also the honorary
president of the World Jewish Congress and a "former president of B'nai
B'rith International, who raised millions of dollars for Israel."
[OLIVER, M., p. A16] In 1959, he was instrumental in holding, for the
first time, the B'nai B'rith yearly gathering in the Jewish state.
[GRUSD, E., 1966, p. 268] Carter's Secretary of Treasury, W. Michael
Blumenthal was also of Jewish heritage, as was his Secretary of
Defense, Harold Brown. Philip Klutznick was Secretary of
Commerce and Neil Goldschmidt was Secretary of Transportation.
"Two of the top nine aides" to Carter were also Jewish, Robert
Lipshutz (formerly head of the Atlanta chapter of B'nai B'rith) and
Stuart Eizenstat. Other prominent Jewish officials in the Carter
administration included Kenneth Axelson, Anthony Solomon,
Julius Katz, and Arthur Borg. [LILIENTHAL, A., p. 236;
PLESUR, M., 1982, p. 142] Robert S. Strauss [was] "Carter's
choice for almost everything." [PLESUR, M., 1982, p. 143]
Under Republican president Gerald
Ford, prominent individuals of Jewish heritage included Henry
Kissinger (Secretary of State), James Schlesinger (Secretary
of Defense), and Edward Levi (Attorney General). History could
have been different: Kissinger's parents almost emigrated from
Germany to Israel. [GOLDMANN, N., 1978, p. 158] "You are much more
Jewish unconsciously than consciously," Zionist lobbyist Nachum
Goldmann once told him. "This," wrote Goldmann, "is quite apparent in
his attitude to Israel." [GOLDMANN, N., 1978, p. 163] "During Israel's
first years as a nation," notes Steven Silbiger, "the United States
offered it very little financial or military aid. The huge influx of
direct aid occurred during the Nixon administration in the 1970s under
the leadership of Secretary of State Henry Kissinger, the first
Jew to hold the position. Aid skyrocketed from $300 million to $2.2
billion annually, making Israel the recipient of more U.S. dollars than
any other nation." [SILBIGER, S., 2000, p. 52]
Appointed positions, however, are
not everything. Nor are electoral seats, of course, the real locus of
political power. "The one question that Jewish activists tend to tiptoe
around," wrote Stephen Isaacs in 1974, "is the one concerning Jewish
money ... Jewish money has played a significant role in the current
exercise of power ... [It] can sometimes play a major factor in whether
a senator has won re-election." [ISAACS, p. 260] "It is one of the
worst-kept secrets in American Jewish politics," noted J. J. Goldberg,
"that the campaign contribution is a major key to Jewish power ...
Almost none of those involved in the process of Jewish campaign funding
... donors, fundraisers, candidates, monitors ... are willing to talk
about it on the record ... Jews fear that discussing Jewish money will
encourage anti-Semitic conspiracy theories. Non-Jews fear that talking
about it will leave them open to charges of anti-Semitism. But it is a
fact ... [GOLDBERG, JJ, p. 266] ... The most notorious use of Jewish
campaign money is not to support candidates who have been friendly, but
to oppose those who have been unfriendly." [GOLDBERG, JJ, p. 269]
Jewish money in Washington D. C. was
even crucial in the very founding of the modern state of Israel. Jewish
Democrats Dewey Stone, Abe Feinberg, Ed Kaufmann,
and others were key fundraisers for Harry Truman's Presidential
campaigns; they were also Zionists. Going against the will of his own
State Department, Truman followed the Zionist line in supporting a 1947
United Nations vote for the partition of Palestine into Jewish and Arab
sections. Afterwards, said long time Democratic activist and
brother-in-law of John F. Kennedy, Stephen Smith: "Two million dollars
went aboard the Truman [campaign] train in a paper bag, and that's what
paid for the state of Israel." [COCKBURN, p. 26-27]
During the Franklin D. Roosevelt
administration, "at the urging of [prominent wealthy Jews] Henry
Morgenthau, Sr. and Felix Warburg" the president appointed
James D. McDonald as "high commissioner for refugees (Jewish and others)
coming from Germany ... The bulk of financial support McDonald received
came from private Jewish relief societies. Of his advisory council of
twenty voluntary agencies, ten were Jewish, and Felix Warburg was
personally obliged to supplement McDonald's meager salary ... McDonald
[was] ... a lifetime supporter of Jewish causes and eventually [became]
America's first ambassador to Israel." [NICHOLS, p. 43-44] "The State
Department representatives [among advisers to President Truman]," notes
Melvin Urofsky, "strongly urged that a trained foreign service career
officer be nominated, but the President [Truman] after politely
listening to their nominees (nearly all of whom came from the Middle
East desk), chose James G. McDonald." [UROFSKY, M., 1978, p. 186] Under
Secretary of State Robert Lovette, for example, "questioned whether
McDonald's known sympathy for the Zionist cause ought not to disqualify
him." [UROFSKY, M., 1978, p. 187]
John F. Kennedy had a strongly
negative reaction in 1960 to the conditions Jewish contributors demanded
for their donations to his presidential campaign (their "initial"
contribution was $500,000). Seymour Hersh notes a conversation Kennedy
had with a friend, newspaper columnist Charles L. Bartlett:
"'As an American citizen [Kennedy]
was outraged,' Bartlett recalled,
'to have a Zionist group come to
him and say: We know your
campaign is in trouble. We're
willing to pay your bill, if you'll let
us have control of your Middle
East policy.' Kennedy, as a
presidential candidate, also
resented the crudity with which he'd
been approached. 'They wanted
control,' he angrily told Bartlett."
[HERSH, p. 97]
Among these Jews was Abraham
Feinberg, president of the Israel Bonds Organization, who "had
helped bankroll Harry S. Truman's seemingly doomed 1948 presidential
campaign; by the presidential campaign of 1960 he was perhaps the most
important Jewish fundraiser for the Democratic Party. There was nothing
subtle in his message: the dollars he collected were meant to insure
continued Democratic Party support for Israel." [HERSH, p. 93] "My
partner to power," said Feinberg, "was cooperation in terms of
what they needed -- campaign money. " [HERSH, p. 94] To appease Jewish
interest in Kennedy's White House, Myer Feldman, a liaison to the
Jewish American community, was also afforded extraordinary access to
"monitor all of the State Department and White House cable traffic on
the Middle East." [HERSH, p. 99] Robert Kennedy, the president's
brother, noted in an interview published in 1988 that Feldman's
"major interest was Israel rather than the United States." [HERSH, p.
100] Feldman also helped write Kennedy speeches and was "an
adviser to columnists Drew Pearson and Jack Anderson." [BLUMAY, C.,
1992, p. 66] Also, 'One of Kennedy's most trusted, and little-known
advisers during the 1960 campaign [was] Hyman Raskin, a Chicago
lawyer who had helped manage Adlai Stevenson's presidential campaign in
1952 and 1956." [HERSH, S., 1997, p. 90]
Upon election, John F. Kennedy
lobbied unsuccessfully for ways to reform "the financial base of our
presidential campaigns." "In a statement that was far more heartfelt
than the public or press could perceive," says Hersh, "he criticized the
current method of financial campaigns as 'highly undesirable' and 'not
healthy' because it made candidates 'dependent on large financial
contributions of those with special interests.'" [HERSH, p. 97] So
important to Democratic purse strings, Abe Feinberg became
influential in the Kennedy White House and even managed to get the
beholding president to appoint Feinberg's brother, Wilfred,
to a position as a federal judge. [HERSH, p. 97-98] (On the Israeli
side of things, he was eventually rewarded for his lobbying efforts on
behalf of the Jewish state by being allowed to be a principal owner in
the Coca-Cola franchise in Israel. [HERSH, p. 192] Pierre Salinger
was Kennedy's Press Secretary. Even a Jewish New York physician, Max
Jacobson (the infamous "Dr. Feelgood" to so many Hollywood
celebrities), regularly drugged the President with painkillers and
stimulants, so much that some in the White House entourage began to
worry about the President's reliance upon them. "Carrying his bag of
drugs and needles," notes Seymour Hersh, "[Jacobson] 'came and
went' in and out of the White House without challenge. He was part of
the 'inner circle.'" [HERSH, S., 1997, p. 234]
In modern political America, in the
competing attempts to buy influence, one half of major donations to the
Democratic Party is believed to come from Jews, [SLAVIN, p. 20] as is
one half of Democratic Presidential campaign funding. [GOLDBERG, p.
276] As early as 1967, William Domhoff, in Who Rules America?,
found that 50% of the highest echelon of campaign contributors ("of whom
we could find information") to the Democratic Party in 1960 and 1964
were Jews. [DOMHOFF, p. 95] "Jews donate or raise as much as half of all
Democratic Party campaign funds," noted Jewish author Steven Silbiger in
2000, "... Again, to quote the Jewish proverb, 'He who pays has the
say.'" [SILBIGER, S., 2000, p. 55] (In 1968, of 21 people who loaned
Hubert Humphrey more than $100,000 for his failed Presidential bid, 15
were Jewish. [TIVNAN, p. 84] In the Jewish clique near Humphrey, Max
Kampelman was "a major adviser to the senator.") [RADOSH, R., 1996,
p. 6] Understandably, in 1970, Jewish entrepreneur Robert Strauss
was named Treasurer of the Democratic National Committee. "The tiny
world of Democratic political consulting and fundraising is a world that
is dominated by Jews," noted J. J. Goldberg in 1996, "Many of them are
former employees of AIPAC [the pre-eminent pro-Israel political action
committee] and the UJA [United Jewish Appeal]." [GOLDBERG, JJ, p. 275]
(Even the American revolution reputedly relied in great part upon Jewish
money, particularly Hayim Solomon: "Legend has it," says Julia Lieblich,
"that George Washington appealed for funds to financier Hayim Solomon on
the highest of holy days, Yom Kippur.") LIEBLICH, J., 8-19-2000]
In 1977 Steve Chapple and Reebee
Garofalo noted the research of sociologist G. William Domhoff who had
"pointed out that principals in Gulf and Western ..., 20th
Century Fox, and MGM have been part of what he calls the
'Jewish Cowboy' fundraising clique that forms a significant part of the
Democratic party's financial base. Arthur Krim and Robert
Benjamin, key powers at United Artists, and directors of the
parent firm Transamerica have been major Democratic fund raisers
in New York. Benjamin has also been a member of the Council on
Foreign Relations. MCA's Lew Wasserman has also long been
an important behind-the-scenes figure in the Democratic Party."
[CHAPPLE, p. 222]
Investigative journalist Dan Moldea
wrote an entire volume about the relationship of Republican President
Ronald Reagan to MCA, noting that: "President Ronald Reagan's
professional life -- his acting career, his personal fiscal fortune, and
his rise in politics -- has been interwoven with and propelled by a
powerful, Hollywood-based entertainment conglomerate named MCA.
For nearly fifty years, Reagan has benefited both personally and
financially from ... the Music Corporation of America -- as well
as his close associations with the firm's top executives: Jules Stein,
Lew Wasserman, and Taft Schreiber." [MOLDEA, p. 1]
Stein and Schreiber
were prominent Republican activists; Schreiber even was a
co-chairman of the finance committee to re-elect Reagan. [MOLDEA, p.
266] Wasserman, a friend of Reagan's and once his personal
Hollywood agent in his movie years, was, as noted, a prominent Democrat.
"The antitrust problems [MCA had with the government]," notes Dan
Moldea, "would be eliminated in the future by maintaining good relations
with both political parties ... While Stein and Schreiber
covered the GOP, Wasserman was busy making friends with the
Democrats. He became a close friend of Lyndon Johnson, a relationship he
never discussed, and became a key fund-raiser in the Democratic Party."
Wasserman even reportedly turned down an offer to be Johnson's
Secretary of Commerce. [MOLDEA, p. 236] (There were also problems with
MCA's link to organized crime. Wasserman even reportedly risked a
meeting in his office with mobster Meyer Lansky and mob lawyer
Sidney Korshak in 1965). [MCDOUGAL, p. 328]
At an awards ceremony for Wasserman in 2000, notes Mother Jones
magazine, President
"Clinton joked that he had been to so many fundraisers at
Wasserman's home
that, 'I half expected him to prorate this year's property tax and
send me my
share.'" [MOTHER JONES, 5-3-01]
Jews were also key in the Reagan
administration's Iran-Gate scandal [when his administration circumvented
a Congressional ban on funding the Contra rebels of Nicaragua by
secretly selling weapons to Iran and using the resultant money to pay
for Contra weaponry.] Four Israelis -- Yaakov Nimrodi, Al
Schwimmer, David Kimche, and Amiram Nir -- who
"arranged the weapons deliveries" demanded immunity from prosecution
during a Congressional investigation of the matter. [Three Israelis were
also granted immunity in the Jonathan Pollard spy investigation].
[SINAI, R., 1987] The Jerusalem Post reported in 1994 that
[Jewish] National Security Adviser Howard Teicher "was being
called the mastermind of the [Iran-Gate] affair." [RODAN, S., 1994, p.
18] The Jerusalem Report also noted heavy Israeli involvement in
the "October Surprise" that many believed was planned for Reagan to gain
the American presidency: "Regarded just weeks ago as a paranoid
delusion, the theory of a secret 1980 deal between the
Reagan-for-President campaign and revolutionary Iran is now official
Senate business ... Conservative versions of the theory allege that
Israeli officials cooperated with the Reagan campaign in what amounted
to a bid to prolong detention of U.S. hostages [in Iran] to tilt the
1980 election away from incumbent Jimmy Carter ... The current flap
seems to have Israeli fingerprints all over it." [GOLDBERG, J.J.,
6-11-91, p. 26]
Yet another Jewish Iran-Contra
player was Elliot Abrams. "An Assistant Secretary of State under
President Reagan," noted the Jewish Week in 1997, "who pleaded
guilty to two misdemeanor counts during the Iran-Contra scandal, Mr.
Abrams has reinvented himself as a leading advocate of increased
Jewish religiosity." [FORWARD, 11-14-97, p. 14] (Reagan himself went far
out of his way in asserting Jewish allegiance. "Astoundingly," notes
Anthony Bianco, "Reagan once told Israeli prime minister Yitzhak
Shamir that he had seen firsthand the devastation wrought by the
Holocaust as a member of an army film crew that filmed the liberation of
the concentration camps. 'From then on,' Reagan said, 'I was concerned
for the Jewish people.' The fact was, though, that Reagan never left the
United States during World War II and indeed lived at home with his wife
throughout his four years in uniform." [BIANCO, A., 1991, p. 14]
Another angle to Jewish criminal
elements in Washington is the case of Teamsters president Jackie
Presser (also Jewish, he took the helm of the union in 1984).
Presser, well-known to be associated with organized crime (like the
Teamsters itself), was the highest paid union official in America at
$530,000 a year. He was appointed to act as a senior labor adviser in
the Reagan administration (the Teamsters union was the only major labor
organization that supported Reagan's candidacy). [BARRON, p. 4]
Presser's uncle, Allen Friedman, has written a book about his
own life in the union and its links to the underworld. In the Washington
realm, he notes, "a few years ago, Bill Presser handed me a
briefcase he said was filled with cash and told me to take it to [Reagan
official] Edwin Meese in Washington ... After Reagan [became president],
he named Bill's son, Jackie Presser, to his transition cabinet.
Then he wanted to make Jackie under secretary of labor, though I guess
cooler heads prevailed." [FRIEDMAN, A., 1989, p. 3] In the Zionist
realm, "Jackie sold Israel Bonds and raised money to build a
children's home in Israel. He also convinced the Teamsters rank and file
to buy such bonds, the union leadership and locals buying more than 25
per cent of all the bonds sold in the United States in 1977." [FRIEDMAN,
A., 1989, p. 257] (Russell Mokhiber adds that the Teamsters Union "was
not alone in its fondness for the [Israeli] notes. Despite below-market
yields and unusually high risk, some of America's largest unions,
pension funds and major corporations have collectively loaned billions
of dollars to the Israeli government. Israel's violent repression of the
Palestinian uprising in the West Bank and Gaza -- and the threat the
uprising poses to Israel's shaky economy -- appears not to have affected
investor confidence. Nathan Zirkin [also Jewish], comptroller for
the Retail, Wholesale and Department Store Union, told the
Multinational Monitor that his union 'absolutely' plans to continue
purchasing Israel bonds, despite the repression in the occupied
territories. 'The Palestinians didn't have a damn thing until Israel
came in,' Zirkin said." ] MOKHIBER, R., 4-88]
Presser's "close associate" in
Los Angeles, Marty Bacow, was once involved in Detroit's (Jewish)
Purple Gang. [MCDOUGAL, p. 456] Another Jewish Teamster official from
Presser's home state, Harold Friedman, president of the Ohio
Council of Teamsters, was "convicted of racketeering and embezzling" in
1989. [FRIEDMAN, A., 1989, p. 264] In Minnesota, in 1995, the
(Minneapolis) Star Tribune noted a few more Jewish Teamsters in
trouble, including Jack Mogelson, also a former Board Member of
the American Civil Liberties Union in that state:
"Mogelson has been a familiar
figure for decades in labor, civil
rights and political circles in
Minnesota. So when the state's largest
Teamsters' local was placed in
trusteeship earlier this month for
alleged financial improprieties, the
name on everyone's lips was
Mogelson -- not because he is
considered less or more culpable
than his three fellow officials
[president Robert Wiesenburger;
Treasurer David Morris; and
vice president Lawrence Bastian],
but because he's the one people know
... By most accounts
Mogelson is a man of
contrasts: an old style unionist with liberal
leanings, a forceful representative
of law enforcement who has
been arrested for soliciting a
prostitute and who in his youth
took a baseball bat to a cop who was
arresting his brother for
shoplifting ... A dedicated
activist, Mogelson has fought passionately
on a range of issues from workers'
rights to the security of Israel."
[HODGES, J., 5-15-95]
Among other accusations, Teamsters
financial indiscretions by the above officers included $55,000 from
union funds for sports tickets; $28,000 for message therapists; $7,800
for magazine subscriptions; and a $20,000 (apiece) Teamsters raise for
themselves when the union chapter was in financial difficulty.
Then there is the Newspaper and Mail Deliverers Union:
"Formed in the early 1900s, the Newspaper and Mail Deliverers
Union was equal
parts Irish, Italian, and Jewish, a reflection of the city's then
dominant ethnic
groups. Well into the 1970s, Jewish racketeers played a major role
in the union ...
In more recent times, a hustling gangster named Irving Bitz
-- nicknamed 'the
Little Guy' for his diminutive stature -- also helped keep peace
among mob
factions in the industry. Bitz, an NMDU member who also ran
Imperial
News Service, carried his own fearful legend: the feisty
businessman was
credited with the 1931 slaying of famed [Jewish] gambler Legs
Diamond ...
In 1959, [Bitz] was convicted of conspiring with NMDU officials to
control Long Island's newspaper and magazine deliveries. Bitz
remained
a powerful force in the industry up until the day in 1981 when his
trussed-up
body was found in a Staten Island swamp. His murder was never
solved."
[Robbins, T., 3-701]
In 1993 a controversial book about former FBI chief J. Edgar Hoover
appeared, written by Anthony Summers. Subtitled The Secret Life of J.
Edgar Hoover, Summers claimed the decades-long director was a closet
homosexual and cross-dresser. This has been refuted and ridiculed by
others. Summers argued that the reason Hoover didn't -- inexplicably --
corral organized crime was because Meyer Lansky, the Jewish head
of "The Syndicate," had incriminating photographs (or other
documentation) of the FBI director. For what it's worth, fact or
fiction, in this outrageous scenario brewery mogul Lewis Rosentiel
(also Jewish) plays a key role:
"Early in Hoover's career, according to mob interviews, he was
trapped by his
own homosexuality. Mafia boss Meyer Lansky, who specialized
in the use of
damaging information to manipulate men in public life, had
reportedly obtained
compromising evidence -- probably photographs ... [p. 13] ... 'The
homosexual
thing,' said [Lansky associate Sidney] Pollock,
'was Hoover's Achilles' heel.
Meyer found it, and it was like he pulled strings with Hoover. He
never bothered
any of Meyer's people ..." [p. 243] ... By the end of World War II [Rosentiel's]
company, Schenley, had become the leading U. S. distiller ...
Rosentiel's
lifelong involvement with the Mafia came to light only in 1970 ...
[p. 248] ...
[Rosentiel's fourth wife] Susan Rosentiel's final and most
sensational
revelations suggest her husband and [Jewish lawyer] Roy Cohn
[famous as the
right-hand man of Senator Joe McCarthy during the so-called
witch-hunts for
communists in the 1950s] involved Edgar in sex orgies -- thus laying
him
more open than ever to pressure from organized crime." [SUMMERS, A.,
1993,
p. 253]
"In the thirties," adds Summers, "Edgar began a long association
with the columnist who reigned as the nation's premier purveyor of
gossip for thirty years, Walter Winchell [also Jewish]."
[SUMMERS, A., 1993, p. 84] Summers also notes Lansky's underworld
in support of the U.S. government war efforts:
"The OSS [precursor to the CIA] and Naval Intelligence had
extensive contacts
with the Mafia during World War II, enlisting the help of criminals
in projects
including the hiring of burglars and assassins, experimentation
with drugs,
the protection of American ports from Nazi agents and the invasion
of Sicily.
Lansky helped personally with the latter two operations,
meeting with Murray
Gurfein, a New York Assistant District Attorney who later
became one of
William Donovan's most trusted OSS officers." [SUMMERS, A., 1993,
p. 245]
In 1999, a Tennessee newspaper
published an alarming front page article. "The shadow of organized
crime," said the Tennessean,
"has descended on Tennessee's
political landscape, via campaign
contributions from the operator [Rod
Aycox] of Georgia-based 'auto
title' loan companies. The man who
operates these companies was the
top individual contributor to
Tennessee's 1998 political campaigns. Court
documents show he is also a business
partner of a Florida man, Alvin
Malnik,
who has been found to have close ties with the mob ...
Malnik's associates have
included some of the country's top mobsters."
The article is not about Aycox (who
is depicted as merely a mob front), but Malnik, who in 1997
received half the profits of Aycox's businesses and in 1999 completely
bought him out. Malnik, who lives on a 34-acre estate in Boca
Raton, with a private bowling alley and Arabian horse area, was once
director of the Bank World of Commerce, a known shell company for mob
money laundering. Malnik was also a business partner with mobster Sam
Cohen, including a Miami country club built 'with money from the
Teamsters' Pension Fund.'" [WISSNER, S., 3-14-99, p. 1A]
Robert Kennedy once wrote about
another formal (Jewish) Teamster member, Paul Dorfman:
"[Dorfman] was a big operator
-- a major figure in Chicago's underworld
who also knew his way around in
certain labor and political circles ...
[Teamsters boss Jimmy] Hoffa made a
trade with Dorfman. In return
for an introduction to the Chicago
underworld, the [investigating
government] Committee found, Hoffa
turned over to him and his
family the gigantic Central
Conference of Teamsters Welfare Fund
Assistance." [MARRIS, 1989, p. 383]
(Earlier, in 1983, another Dorfman,
Allen, former manager of the Teamster's Central States Pension
Fund, was found murdered). [MOLDEA, 1989, p. 366]
Also from Chicago, came mob-linked
lawyer Sidney Korshak, also Jewish, and a mainstay in every book
about underworld crime and Hollywood. As Dennis McDougal notes:
"While he was gaining a foothold in
Hollywood, Korshak continued
to practice law in the Chicago loop.
Among his closest associates
was Alderman Jacob Arvey, a
celebrated political fixer in his own
right, as well as a pal of Capone
syndicate since the 1920s. Alex
Louis Greenberg's
longtime business partner in Lawndale Enterprises,
Inc., Arvey [also Jewish] was
the most powerful figure in Chicago
politics. Korshak's younger
brother, Marshall, also became an Arvey
protégé and went on to become a state
senator, and one of the primary
conduits between the Chicago Mob and
the Illinois Democratic political
machine." [MCDOUGAL, p. 141]
(Jacob Arvey, notes Harry
Golden, "controlled the Democratic Party in Illinois from 1947 to 1959."
By the early 1970s, seven Jews sat on Chicago's City Council; the
Sheriff of Chicago-area Cook County was also Jewish, as was the mayor's
press secretary, who wrote "many of the mayor's speeches.") "When they
were Democrats," noted Chicago committeeman Bernard Neistein, in
the same era, "the Illinois State Legislature was empowered to invest
surplus funds in Israeli bonds." [GOLDEN, H., 1973, p. 210-211, 216,
218, 220]
Another pal of Sidney Korshak
was yet another Jewish lawyer, Paul Ziffren. In 1960, the
Chairman of the Democratic National Committee praised Paul Ziffren,
saying he "has been the greatest single force and most important
Democrat in the resurgence of the Democratic party in California." Not
long after, a Reader's Digest article outlined "Ziffren's
long-standing ties to major organized crime figures." [MOLDEA, p. 137]
According to a Los Angeles Police Department report, Ziffren was
also a supplier of prostitutes to the wealthy and powerful: "It is a
matter of general police knowledge that Ziffren's name appears in
many of the call girl trick books which are confiscated by police when
these individuals are arrested ... All readily admit to being in the
Ziffren service department." [MCDOUGAL, p. 278]
Many Jewish politicos move in close
quarters. As Dennis McDougal notes:
"Just as Wasserman's close friend and
ally Paul Ziffren quietly
controlled the California delegation
of the Democratic National Committee
for many years, so [Jewish lawyer
Ed] Weisl ran the New York
delegation of the party, particularly
during the 1960s when all three
would become confidants of President
Lyndon Johnson."
[MCDOUGAL, p. 231]
Infamous Jewish lawyer Roy Cohn notes that
"Edward Weisl, Sr., the Democratic power broker who was to
become President
Johnson's chief confidant, poured out an earful of venom against
Supreme
Court Justice William O. Douglas, who had voted against Paramount
Pictures
in a major anti-trust case. Weisl, a good friend of Paramount's
president
Barney Balaban [also Jewish], had gone to Douglas to ask for
his vote.
He thought he had every right to do this because he was one of
Douglas's
closest pals. As Weisel put it to me: 'We got him in as head of the
Security
Exchange Commission, we put him over the rim for the Supreme Court
nomination with FDR when there were five other people ahead of him,
we made the bastard. And now we ask him for something like
this,
something perfectly proper, and he tells us to drop dead.'" [ZION,
S.,
1988, p. 22-23]
Former Democratic National
Committee Chairman Robert Strauss was also, since 1980, a member
of MCA's Board of Directors (Wasserman's company).
[MCDOUGAL, p. 461]
A more recent example of
above-the-table, reputable purse strings influence in Hollywood is the
clout wielded by the three Jewish media moguls -- David Geffen,
Stephen Spielberg, and Jeffrey Katzenburg, and their
personal business empires in recent years melded into one, Dreamworks
SKG. Dreamworks "became the largest contributor to the Democratic
Party with donations totaling over $2 million." [GOODMAN, p. 379] "I
don't want to present myself as a person with influence," Geffen
remarked in an interview. "Then," reports Fred Goodman, "he proceeded to
return telephone calls to Michael Ovitz, Lew Wasserman,
Barry Diller, Ted Field, and several others arranging for them to
meet President Clinton when he passed through Los Angeles the following
night." [GOODMAN, p. 379]
In the election year of 1996, Bill
Clinton's re-election year to the presidency, the top six individual
donators to the Democratic Party were Jewish moguls from Hollywood:
David Geffen -- $575,000
Lew Wasserman -- $507,000
Steven Spielberg -- $503,000
Jeffrey Katzenberg -- $408,000
Sidney Sheinberg
-- $321,000
Edgar Bronfman, Jr. --
$318,000
The three greatest individual
beneficiaries of this political philanthropy were California's two
Jewish senators, Diane Feinstein and Barbara Boxer, and
West Los Angeles (Jewish) Congressman Mel Levine. President
Clinton and Massachusetts Senator Ted Kennedy ranked fourth and fifth in
the amount of money received from the above-mentioned six Jewish moguls.
West Los Angeles Congressman Howard Berman, also Jewish, was the
next ranked beneficiary. [MCDOUGAL, p. 520] In overview, a 1992 Los
Angeles Times article noted Mel Levine to have been the
object of the largest Jewish donations in the city. "When it comes to
the potency of pro-Israel giving," the paper noted, "... Representative
Levine is exhibit A ... Levine has been one of Capitol Hill's most vocal
supporters of Israel." (Levine's father-in-law, Max Greenberg,
once headed the Anti-Defamation League). [MILLER/MORRIS, 1-26-92, p. A1]
And as the Jewish Telegraphic Agency noted after Levine later
left office, "One of [Vice President Al] Gore's oldest and closest
friends in Los Angeles is former Representative Mel Levine."
[TUGEND, T., 2-16-2000, p. 8]
The central members of another --
largely Jewish -- Hollywood Democratic fund-raising political clique of
the 1970s (called by Ronald Brownstein the "Malibu Mafia") included
Sidney Sheinbaum (whose wife is the daughter of film mogul Harry
Warner), Norman Lear, Miles Rubin, Ted Ashley,
Max Palevsky, Harold Willens, and Leopold Wyler.
In 1992, the Los Angeles Times
also singled out another local key Jewish political fundraiser (this one
in the garment business), Stanley Hirsh: "Hirsh is one of
the financial magnets who draws politicians from all over the United
States to Los Angeles." "We have a book at the house," he told the
newspaper, "that my wife keeps with records of annual votes by
candidates that we follow. A lot of it is how they vote on Israel [and
two other issues]." "[MILLER/MORRIS, 1-26-92, p. A1] The Times
article focused on the treasure trove of (overwhelmingly Jewish)
political money available from the wealthy of the city, noting that
"For individual candidates from
either party, supporting Israel may
well be the single most important
thing they can do to help themselves
raise money in Los Angeles. Above
all else, this means voting for
the annual foreign aid bill, which
currently contains $3 billion for
Israel ... Most of the biggest
political beneficiaries of Los Angeles
largesse in 1989 and 1990 are
regarded as important friends of the
Jewish state ... [Paul Simon of
Illinois] became a hero to the pro-
Israeli community in 1984 when he
ousted former Sen. Charles H.
Percy, an influential critic of
Israel ... By all accounts [Congressional]
pro-Israel credentials give them
special entree and appeal." [MILLER/
MORRIS, 1-26-92, p. A1]
Elsewhere, in 1998, billionaire
Chaim Saban, "the biggest Israeli player in Hollywood, ... hosted a
fund-raiser at his home [in Los Angeles] for President Clinton that
yielded $1.5 million in donations." [TUGEND, T., 3-28-99] ["The Sabans,"
notes the New York Times, "have given as much as $10 million over
the years to the Democratic Party and its candidates." [WEINRAUB, B.,
3-4-01, sec. 3, p. 2] (In Canada, Gerald Schwartz, head of the
Onex corporation, friend of both liberal and conservative politicians,
"became a major fundraiser." ) [NOBLE, K., 10-11-99] Margery Tabankin,
also Jewish, headed the "powerful Hollywood Women's Political Committee"
and "ruled the glittering world of left-liberal political fundraising in
Tinseltown" till 1997 when she took over the reins of Steven Spielberg's
$55 million Spielberg Foundation. "She also heads the Barbard Streisand
Foundation." [FORWARD, 1-5-01]
Across the country, at America's
other nerve center, in 1994, Crain's New York Business journal
published the results of a report listing "New York's top contributors
to federal elections, parties, and political action committees." All of
the top five money donors mentioned were Jewish: Bernard Schwartz,
CEO of the Loral Corporation; Maurice Templeton, chairman of
Lazare Kaplan International; Arthur Ortenberg, co-founder
of Liz Claibourne Inc.; Robert Rubin, former co-chairman of
Goldman Sachs & Co. and later a Bill Clinton cabinet member; and
Jeffrey Keil, president of the Republic New York Corporation.
[FEIDEN, p. 6] In October 2000, the Israeli newspaper Ha'aretz
noted that S. Daniel Abraham, founder of the Slim-Fast company,
was "the Democratic Party's single heaviest private donor, contributing
no less than $993,000 over the past 18 months." [LEIBOVICH-DAR, S.,
10-13-2000]
In 2001, Mother Jones magazine listed the top 400 individual
contributors to political [Democratic and Republican] campaigns. [MOTHER
JONES, MAY 2001] These are the people who seek to influence the American
political process by economic means. Although Jews represent merely 2.5%
of the American population, at least 41 (and quite likely
a few more) of the first 100 people listed were Jewish, including four
of the top five. Of these first four, three are noted as having strong
ties to Israel:
#1 was S. Daniel Abraham, former mogul of Slim Fast Foods,
who "has spent most of his political and charitable energies in
the last decade supporting Israel and the troubled Middle East
peace process. He has helped fund Birthright Israel, a program which
sponsors tours of Israel for young American Jews." Abraham
contributed $1,518,500
to the Democratic Party.
#2 was Bernard Schwartz, CEO of Loral Space and
Communications, a defense
contractor moving more and more into the telecommunications
industry. Schwartz
donated $1,317,000 to the Democratic Party.
# 3 was David Gilo, head of the wireless communications
company, Vyyo. Gilo
was born in Israel and "emigrated to the United States in 1982,
retaining dual
citizenship." Gilo contributed $1,311,000 to the Democratic Party.
#5 was Haim Saban, who is also immigrant from Israel.
More Jews on the list of the nation's biggest economic string-pullers
include:
9. Constance Milstein -- "born to one of New York's most
promine